Abortion should be legal when the mother’s life is in danger.

Understanding the Argument

Pregnancy can worsen serious heart, kidney, vascular, or other medical conditions. Obstetric emergencies such as severe preeclampsia, placental abruption, hemorrhage, infection, or ectopic pregnancy can threaten a woman’s life.

According to this argument, doctors must be free to end the pregnancy before the woman becomes critically ill. ACOG therefore maintains that abortion can sometimes be medically necessary.

Treating the Condition is Different Than An Induced Abortion

A dangerous pregnancy sometimes must end. Pro-life medicine does not require doctors to stand by while a woman deteriorates or dies.

The critical distinction is between:

  • Ending the pregnancy to treat the mother, while attempting to preserve both lives whenever possible
  • Intentionally causing the child’s death before or during separation

AAPLOG defines direct abortion as an intervention intended to ensure fetal death. It distinguishes that from medically necessary treatment that ends a pregnancy even when the child’s death is foreseen.

The most precise pro-life claim is not that pregnancy never needs to end. It is that the child’s intentional death should never become the treatment.

“Direct abortion is not medically necessary to save the life of a woman.”

Dublin Declaration, affirmed by AAPLOG

“There is no such thing as a medically necessary abortion. Ever.”

Dr. Monique Ruberu, a board-certified OB-GYN

The Principle of Double Effect

The principle of double effect explains how a doctor may perform a necessary treatment that has both a good effect and a foreseen harmful effect.

The action may be morally permissible when:

  • The treatment itself addresses a serious medical condition.
  • The doctor intends the good effect, such as saving the mother.
  • The child’s death is foreseen but not intended.
  • The child’s death is not used as the means of saving the mother.
  • The danger is serious enough to justify the treatment.

For example, removing a dangerously damaged fallopian tube in an ectopic pregnancy saves the mother’s life but results in the embryo’s death. The doctor removes the pathological tube rather than attacking the child as the object of treatment.

Likewise, delivering a child early because of severe preeclampsia may be necessary even when the child is too premature to survive. The purpose is to end the dangerous pregnancy and save the mother, not to ensure the child’s death.

The goal of the treatment is to save the mother. The goal of abortion is to kill the unborn child.

The goal of the treatment is to target the condition harming the mother. The goal of abortion is to target the unborn child.

Delivery Can Protect the Mother Without First Killing the Child

When an intrauterine pregnancy must end, doctors may deliver the child through induction or cesarean birth, depending on the gestational age, urgency, and mother’s condition.

In a true later-pregnancy emergency, an emergency C-section can deliver a child within minutes. ACOG acknowledges that when the situation poses an immediate threat, delivery may need to occur in a matter of minutes.

By comparison, many abortions later in pregnancy require a longer process. Society of Family Planning guidance recommends at least one day of cervical preparation before most D&Es performed between 20 and 24 weeks. UCSF describes procedures between 24 and 26 weeks as generally requiring two nights of cervical preparation, medication, and a fetal injection.

If a woman must no longer be pregnant immediately, spending a day or more preparing to kill and remove the child does not offer the speed of emergency delivery.

This does not apply to an ectopic pregnancy because the embryo is outside the uterus.

When urgent delivery can separate the patients and protect the mother, intentionally causing fetal death first is unnecessary.

When urgent delivery can separate the patients and protect the mother, intentionally causing fetal death first is unnecessary.

What Abortion Does the the Child

Abortion does more than end the pregnancy. Its procedures are intended to ensure that the pregnancy does not result in a living child.

During a dilation and evacuation, forceps enter the uterus and grasp and dismember the child’s body. The arms, legs, torso, and skull are removed in pieces, and the clinician examines the remains to confirm that no fetal parts have been left inside the woman. The World Health Organization’s clinical instructions describe extracting fetal parts with forceps and confirming that all parts are present.

For some abortions later in pregnancy, digoxin or potassium chloride is injected into the child or umbilical cord to stop the fetal heart. Medication then induces labor, and the mother delivers her dead child. Society of Family Planning guidance notes that digoxin can take several hours to produce fetal asystole.

These actions are different from delivering a living child and providing whatever treatment or comfort is possible. One separates mother and child because the pregnancy has become dangerous. The other makes the child’s death part of the procedure.

Survival at 21 Weeks Is Now Documented

Abortion early in pregnancy is not moral, but it is blatantly unjustifiable later in pregnancy for the excuse of the mother’s life considering possible viability should an early delivery be needed.

Viability is not a fixed moment, as is proven by earlier and earlier survival rates as medical technology improves.

A recent single-center case series reported that six of seventeen infants who received attempted resuscitation after being born alive at 21 weeks survived to NICU discharge. The youngest survivor was born at exactly 21 weeks.

When a child may survive, delivery followed by neonatal care is more just than a procedure designed to guarantee death.

When the Child Cannot Survive

Sometimes doctors know that a child delivered early will almost certainly die. The child may be far below viability or have a life-limiting condition.

That does not make intentionally killing the child necessary.

The child can be delivered and given warmth, pain relief, and comfort through perinatal palliative care. Parents may be able to hold, name, photograph, bless, or baptize their child, depending on their beliefs. They can say goodbye and arrange a respectful burial rather than having their child’s dismembered remains treated as medical waste.

ACOG recognizes perinatal palliative comfort care as an established option. It allows doctors to avoid futile or burdensome treatment without intentionally causing the child’s death.

A brief life is still a life. The certainty that someone will die does not make deliberately killing that person an appropriate response.

The Pro-Life Position Protects Both Patients

The pro-life position does not demand that a woman die for her child. It recognizes that obstetricians may face tragic situations in which they cannot save both patients.

When both can be saved, doctors should save both.

When only the mother can be saved, doctors should treat her even if the child’s death is unavoidable.

What they should not do is redefine the intentional killing of the child as the treatment itself.

The moral difference lies in what the doctor intends and does: saving one life when two cannot be saved is not the same as deliberately taking one life to benefit the other.