Abortion should be legal in cases of rape or incest

Understanding the Argument

Pregnancy resulting from rape or incest can compound an already horrific trauma. The woman or girl may experience the pregnancy as a continuing physical reminder of the violence committed against her.

Requiring her to continue the pregnancy, the argument says, forces her to bear the physical and emotional consequences of a crime she did not choose or cause. Supporters of an exception therefore argue that abortion allows her to regain control over her body and avoid further suffering.

These Cases Matter But They Are Extremely Rare

The best-known national survey of abortion patients found that approximately 1% cited rape and fewer than 0.5% cited incest as reasons for their abortions.

While these cases are extremely important, rape and incest cannot reasonably be used to justify the overwhelming majority of abortions that do not involve either circumstance.

Someone making the claim that assault is the reason behind their support for abortion must answer this question:
If rape is the reason behind your support for abortion access, then would you be open to only allowing abortions for rape victims while making it illegal for the other 99% of elective abortions? If not, then is your motivation really about the victims?

If rape is the reason behind your support for abortion access, then would you be open to only allowing abortions for rape victims while making it illegal for the other 99% of elective abortions? If not, then is your motivation really about the victims?

The Child is Not The Perpetrator

Rape is an act of violence committed by the rapist. The unborn child did not cause the assault, participate in it, or choose the circumstances of conception.

Our outrage should therefore be directed at the person who committed the crime, not at the innocent child who resulted from it. We do not normally punish children for their fathers’ crimes, even when those crimes are especially horrific.

The rapist deserves punishment. The mother deserves protection, compassion, and support. The child should not receive a death sentence for an act committed by someone else.

The Circumstances of Conception Do Not Change the Child

A child conceived through rape develops in the same way as a child conceived within a loving relationship. Nothing about the child’s body, humanity, or stage of development reveals whether conception resulted from love or violence.

You could not look at two unborn children and determine which was conceived through rape and which was conceived through love. The children are not different kinds of human beings.

How someone came into existence may be tragic, but it does not determine that person’s value. Human worth cannot depend on whether someone’s biological father acted lovingly or criminally.

You could not look at two unborn children and determine which was conceived through rape and which was conceived through love.

Abortion Cannot Undo The Rape

Continuing such a pregnancy may be emotionally and physically difficult. A pro-life response should never pretend otherwise or blame the woman for what happened to her.

However, abortion cannot erase the assault or punish the attacker. It ends the life of the only other person involved who is completely innocent.

This is not an argument that the woman must feel a particular way about the pregnancy. It is an argument that trauma does not make intentionally killing an innocent human being morally justified.

Incest Requires Protection and Intervention

Incest frequently involves coercion, abuse, exploitation, or the rape of a minor. The victim must be removed from danger, given appropriate medical and trauma-informed care, and protected from further contact with the abuser. Evidence should be properly preserved, authorities should be notified when required, and the perpetrator should be prosecuted.

Medical organizations emphasize that survivors need timely treatment, emotional safety, informed consent, follow-up care, and support that avoids further traumatization.

Abortion alone does not remove an abuser from the home or guarantee that the abuse will stop. The underlying crime must be exposed and confronted.

A Compassionate Pro-Life Response

A woman carrying a child conceived through rape should not be abandoned or treated as though pregnancy is an easy answer. She may need:

  • Immediate safety from the attacker
  • Medical and trauma-informed care
  • Counseling and long-term emotional support
  • Legal assistance and protection from the rapist
  • Financial, housing, and practical help
  • Support for parenting or adoption, depending on her decision

Compassion requires caring for the woman without intentionally killing her child. The violence of rape should be answered with justice for the rapist, healing and support for the mother, and protection for the innocent life that now exists.

Mothers Who Chose Life After Rape

Women respond to pregnancies resulting from rape in different ways, and no individual story represents every survivor. However, many women who continued their pregnancies have publicly described loving their children and being grateful that they did not abort them.

Mary Jane “M.J.” Lockemy

M.J. Lockemy became pregnant after being attacked by a serial rapist in 1983. Although abortion was suggested and members of her family questioned her decision, she continued the pregnancy and gave birth to Anne Farrens.

Decades later, Lockemy said she would not change her decision because of the good that came from her daughter’s life. Anne has likewise said that she is grateful to be alive and that the violence surrounding her conception does not determine her worth.

Jennifer Christie

Jennifer Christie became pregnant after being raped and severely beaten while traveling for work. She and her husband continued the pregnancy and welcomed a son.

Christie has spoken openly about the lasting physical and emotional effects of the assault, but she does not regard her son as an extension of the rapist. She describes him as her child and has said, “We are infinitely richer for this child being in the world.”

Lianna Rebolledo

Lianna Rebolledo became pregnant after being abducted and raped at age 12. Despite the trauma, medical concerns, and difficulty of becoming a mother so young, she continued the pregnancy and raised her daughter, Jeannette.

Rebolledo has said that she had no regrets about giving birth and that her daughter helped bring healing and purpose into her life. She later described Jeannette as the greatest gift she had ever received.

Analyn Megison

Analyn Megison is a rape survivor and mother who became an advocate for other women raising children conceived through sexual assault. She has explained that looking at her child does not make her think of the rapist. Instead, she feels gratitude for her child and for the love and joy she has experienced through motherhood.

These accounts do not erase the trauma of rape or suggest that continuing such a pregnancy is easy. They demonstrate that a child conceived through violence does not necessarily remain a symbol of that violence. For some survivors, the child becomes someone deeply loved and a source of meaning, joy, and healing.