Understanding the Argument
The bodily autonomy argument holds that every person has the right to control what happens within and to his or her body.
Pregnancy substantially affects a woman’s body, health, freedom, and future. Because no one is ordinarily required to provide bodily support to another person, abortion advocates argue that the government should not force a woman to remain pregnant.
Some versions of the argument do grant that the unborn child is, indeed, a person with a right to life. They maintain, however, that a right to life does not include a right to use another person’s body without continuing consent.
Bodily autonomy is important but not absolute
People possess strong rights over their bodies; however, bodily autonomy does not include an unlimited right to use one’s body in ways that seriously harm another person.
A person may not use bodily autonomy to justify assault, neglect a dependent child, or expose others to grave danger. Laws regularly restrict bodily choices when those choices violate another person’s rights.
An abortion restriction does limit a woman’s freedom to choose abortion. The pro-life position is that this limitation is justified because abortion intentionally ends the life of another human being.
The central question is therefore not whether bodily autonomy matters. It is whether bodily autonomy includes the right to intentionally kill the unborn child.
Abortion involves two human bodies
The phrase “my body, my choice” focuses exclusively on the woman’s body.
Pregnancy, however, involves two living human organisms. The unborn child has a distinct body, DNA, circulatory system, and developing organs. The child is located within the woman’s body but is not a part of her body in the same way as an organ or tissue.
A woman therefore has authority over her own body, but abortion is not an action affecting only her body. It also causes the death of the distinct human being developing within her.
The child is located within the woman’s body but is not a part of her body in the same way as an organ or tissue.
Refusing assistance is not always the same as intentionally killing
Bodily autonomy arguments often compare abortion to refusing blood, bone marrow, or organ donation.
In those cases, another person is already dying from an illness or injury. Refusing to donate may allow the disease to cause that person’s death, but the refusal does not create the underlying fatal condition.
The unborn child is ordinarily healthy for his or her developmental stage. Abortion does not merely decline to cure an illness. It deliberately intends for the child’s death.
This creates a moral difference between refusing extraordinary medical assistance and intentionally ending the life of a healthy, dependent human being.
Abortion does not merely decline to cure an illness. It deliberately intends for the child’s death.
Parents have special obligations to their children
The bodily autonomy argument often treats the unborn child as though he or she were a stranger making an unauthorized demand, such as in The Famous Violinist argument.
Pregnancy is instead a parent-child relationship. Parents ordinarily have responsibilities toward their dependent children that they do not have toward unrelated adults.
These obligations require parents to provide food, shelter, protection, and age-appropriate care, often at considerable personal cost. Parents are not required to prevent every harm or make every possible sacrifice, but they may not intentionally kill their children to escape the burdens of caring for them.
If a woman and her newborn were trapped in a cabin during a snowstorm and the only form of sustenance for the child was the mother’s breastmilk, does the woman have a right to refuse to use her body to feed the child?
Pregnancy is not organ donation
Continuing a pregnancy is not the same as forcing someone to donate a kidney.
Kidney donation gives part of one person’s body to someone whose own body is sick or injured. An unborn child is not dying from a disease or failing to sustain himself or herself in an abnormal way. The child is alive, growing, and developing naturally for that stage of life.
The uterus is the child’s natural environment before birth. It temporarily provides the protection, oxygen, and nourishment that every human being needs at this stage of development.
Pregnancy and organ donation are different kinds of bodily support. The fact that the law does not force extraordinary medical donations does not logically prove that a parent may intentionally end the life of a child already living and developing in the natural environment for his or her age.
An unborn child is not dying from a disease or failing to sustain himself or herself in an abnormal way. The child is alive, growing, and developing naturally for that stage of life.
Not intending pregnancy does not remove responsibility
A woman can agree to sex without intending to become pregnant, but not intending a result does not remove every responsibility when that result occurs. People can become responsible for someone through their voluntary actions, especially when those actions create a vulnerable human being who depends on them.
Contraception lowers the chance of pregnancy, but it does not change what happens if conception occurs. A new human being now exists. The question is no longer only whether the pregnancy was wanted, but what the parents owe the child they created and what they may permissibly do to that child.
Not intending to conceive the child does not make the child less human or erase parental and moral obligations toward him or her.
Not intending to conceive the child does not erase parental and moral obligations toward him or her.
Rape does not change the child’s identity
Pregnancy resulting from rape is fundamentally different because the woman did not voluntarily participate in the act that caused conception.
She has been subjected to a profound injustice and bears no responsibility for the assault. The rapist should be held responsible, and the woman deserves protection, medical care, and sustained support.
The pro-life response is that the unborn child did not commit the assault and is not an aggressor. The circumstances of conception do not change the child’s identity or make the child responsible for the father’s crime.
The burden imposed on the mother is especially severe, but intentionally killing the innocent child does not undo the rape nor punish the perpetrator.