Judith Jarvis Thomson

Judith Jarvis Thomson (1929–2020) was an American philosopher whose work shaped modern debates in ethics, rights, and moral responsibility. She taught at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology for most of her career and also made important contributions to discussions of the trolley problem. Within abortion ethics, she is best known for her 1971 essay, A Defense of Abortion.

Rather than arguing that the fetus is not a person, Thomson temporarily grants “for the sake of argument” that the fetus has a right to life from conception. She then asks whether that right necessarily includes the right to use another person’s body.

“The Famous Violinist Hypothetical”

Her best-known thought experiment asks readers to imagine waking up involuntarily connected to a famous unconscious violinist. The violinist needs the use of the reader’s kidneys for nine months to remain alive. Thomson argues that although disconnecting would result in his death, his right to life does not automatically entitle him to continued use of another person’s body.

Thomson uses this analogy to argue that abortion may be morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person. Her argument helped shift the abortion debate from “Is the fetus a person?” to “Does a person’s right to life include a right to another person’s body?”

Thomson did not claim that every abortion is morally acceptable. She acknowledged that some abortions could be selfish or morally indecent, even if they should remain legally permissible. She also distinguished a right to end bodily support from a right to ensure the child’s death if the child could be removed alive.

Critics argue that the violinist analogy differs from most pregnancies in morally important ways:

  • The violinist is a stranger, while the fetus is the woman’s child.
  • The reader was kidnapped and forcibly connected, while 99% of pregnancies follow consensual sexual activity.
  • Disconnecting from illness-related life support allows the violinist to die, whereas abortion acts directly upon a healthy developing human.
  • A kidney sustains another person in an extraordinary medical arrangement, while the uterus ordinarily functions to support a woman’s developing child.
  • Parents may have obligations toward their dependent children that they do not have toward strangers.

Despite these objections, Thomson’s essay remains one of the most influential philosophical defenses of abortion and a foundation for contemporary bodily-autonomy arguments.