Who Is Christopher Kaczor?
Christopher Kaczor is an American moral philosopher and Professor of Philosophy at Loyola Marymount University. His work focuses on ethics, bioethics, natural law, human dignity, happiness, and the thought of Thomas Aquinas.
Kaczor is best known in the abortion debate for The Ethics of Abortion: Women’s Rights, Human Life, and the Question of Justice. Rather than relying upon religious authority, the book uses philosophical reasoning to examine when personhood begins and whether abortion can be justified.
His Argument Against Abortion
Kaczor’s argument can be summarized as follows:
- A new human organism begins to exist at fertilization.
- This organism is the same individual throughout embryonic, fetal, infant, and adult development.
- All human beings possess basic dignity and rights, regardless of age, ability, or dependency.
- Abortion intentionally kills a prenatal human being.
- Therefore, abortion is generally an unjust violation of a human being’s right to life.
Kaczor’s work concentrates particularly on the second and third premises. He examines whether there is a convincing reason to recognize personhood at some point after fertilization and concludes that the proposed dividing lines are inconsistent or arbitrary.
Personhood as Endowment
Kaczor defends an endowment view of personhood. Under this view, human beings possess basic moral worth because of the kind of beings they are, not because of abilities they can currently exercise.
An embryo cannot presently reason, communicate, or make choices. Nevertheless, the embryo is a living human organism with an internal orientation toward developing these abilities. The embryo’s development is the activity of the same individual, not the construction of a new person from something that was previously nonhuman.
Kaczor contrasts this with a performance view, under which personhood depends upon presently functioning abilities such as consciousness, self-awareness, rationality, or the ability to form desires.
When Does Personhood Begin?
Kaczor examines several proposed starting points for personhood:
| Proposed point | Kaczor’s response |
|---|---|
| After birth | Newborns lack many of the abilities sometimes required for personhood, making it difficult to explain why infanticide is wrong. |
| At birth | Location and method of nourishment change at birth, but the child remains the same individual immediately before and after delivery. |
| Viability | Viability depends partly upon available medical technology and location, not an internal change in the child’s humanity. |
| Consciousness or pain perception | Temporary unconsciousness does not ordinarily eliminate a human being’s rights or identity. |
| Brain development | Brain function develops gradually, making it difficult to identify a nonarbitrary moment when a nonperson becomes a person. |
| Implantation | Implantation changes the embryo’s relationship to the mother but does not create a new organism. |
| Fertilization | A distinct human organism begins to exist, providing a clear and biologically grounded starting point. |
The Problem with Gradual Personhood
Some philosophers argue that moral status increases gradually as the fetus develops. Under this view, a late-term fetus may possess greater moral value than an early embryo.
Kaczor agrees that human abilities develop gradually but denies that basic human worth develops in the same way. Intelligence, strength, awareness, and independence exist in degrees, but the right not to be intentionally killed cannot depend upon possessing more of these characteristics.
Otherwise, human beings with greater mental abilities could possess stronger basic rights than newborns or people with serious cognitive disabilities.
Bodily Autonomy
Kaczor addresses the argument that a woman may have a right to abortion even if the unborn child is a person. He argues that bodily autonomy is important but does not include an unrestricted right to cause another human being’s death.
His response emphasizes several points:
- The unborn child is the mother’s offspring rather than an unrelated stranger.
- Parents have special responsibilities toward their dependent children.
- Pregnancy ordinarily provides the care appropriate to a human being at that stage of development.
- Abortion generally involves intentionally causing death, not merely allowing someone to die from an unrelated condition.
- A right to end pregnancy does not necessarily establish a right to ensure the child’s death if the child could be removed alive.
Kaczor also distinguishes between intending death and accepting death as an unintended consequence of necessary medical treatment, such as treatment performed to save a pregnant woman’s life.
Difficult Circumstances
Kaczor considers pregnancies involving rape, threats to the mother’s life, fetal disability, poverty, and other serious hardships. He argues that these circumstances can greatly affect the compassion and assistance owed to a woman, but they do not change what kind of being the unborn child is.
His position is that justice requires supporting both mother and child rather than addressing suffering by intentionally killing the more dependent individual.
Dialogue with Abortion-Rights Philosophers
Kaczor engages directly with philosophers including Judith Jarvis Thomson, Mary Anne Warren, Peter Singer, David Boonin, Don Marquis, and Jeff McMahan.
In Abortion Rights: For and Against, Kaczor and abortion-rights philosopher Kate Greasley each present their strongest case, respond to the other, and offer final replies. This format makes Kaczor’s work especially useful for readers who want to understand serious arguments from both sides.
Major Works
| Work | Significance |
|---|---|
| The Ethics of Abortion | A systematic examination of personhood, women’s rights, bodily autonomy, and the morality of abortion |
| Abortion Rights: For and Against, with Kate Greasley | A structured debate between philosophers on opposing sides of abortion |
| A Defense of Dignity | Applies human dignity to abortion, reproductive technology, medical care, and other bioethical questions |
| Disputes in Bioethics | Addresses beginning-of-life and end-of-life controversies through philosophical analysis |
| The Edge of Life | Examines the moral status and treatment of human beings near the beginning and end of life |
Influence
Kaczor is notable for addressing abortion arguments in a systematic and accessible way. His work does not simply assert that life begins at fertilization. It examines the competing philosophical standards for personhood and asks whether any later point can explain equal human rights without also endangering newborns or other vulnerable people.
His work complements that of Patrick Lee, Robert P. George, and Francis J. Beckwith while giving particular attention to competing theories of personhood and the strongest academic arguments for abortion rights.