Natural Law Ethics

What Is Natural Law Ethics?

Natural law ethics is the view that moral truths are grounded in human nature and can be discovered through reason. It holds that certain things are objectively good for human beings, such as life, knowledge, friendship, family, and justice. Actions are morally right when they respect these goods and help human beings flourish.

Natural law does not simply mean following whatever occurs in nature. Nor does it mean that every natural process is morally good. It asks what human beings are, what genuinely fulfills them, and what principles should guide rational choices.

Although natural law has deep roots in Greek and Christian philosophy, its arguments are not limited to religious revelation. Natural-law thinkers generally maintain that its basic principles can be understood through human reason, including by people who do not share a particular religious faith.

Classical Natural Law

Natural law thinking can be traced through philosophers such as Aristotle and the Stoics, but it received its most influential formulation in the work of Thomas Aquinas.

Aquinas taught that human beings naturally recognize certain basic moral principles. The most fundamental is that good should be pursued and evil avoided. More specific duties arise from basic human goods and inclinations, including the preservation of life, the formation of families, the education of children, the pursuit of truth, and life within a just community.

Under this view, morality is not created entirely by governments, personal preferences, or social agreement. Human laws should reflect objective principles of justice, although applying those principles to particular situations often requires careful judgment.

The New Natural Law Theory

Modern thinkers such as Germain Grisez, John Finnis, Joseph Boyle, Robert P. George, and Patrick Lee developed an approach sometimes called the New Natural Law Theory.

John Finnis identifies several basic human goods, including:

  • Life and health
  • Knowledge
  • Friendship and community
  • Play
  • Appreciation of beauty
  • Practical reasonableness
  • Religion or reflection on ultimate questions

These goods provide fundamental reasons for action. They are not merely useful because they produce pleasure or satisfy someone’s preferences. They are valuable aspects of human flourishing in themselves.

New natural law theorists argue that people should remain reasonably open to every basic good. A person may sometimes be unable to preserve every good, but it is wrong intentionally to attack or destroy a basic good as the means to some further goal.

Human Life as a Basic Good

Natural law ethics recognizes human life as a basic and intrinsic good. A person’s life does not become valuable only after that person develops intelligence, independence, self-awareness, or social usefulness.

Human beings possess a rational nature even when they cannot presently exercise rational abilities. An embryo, infant, sleeping adult, person under anesthesia, and person with a profound cognitive disability may differ greatly in development and ability, but each remains a human being with the same underlying nature.

This is closely connected to the Human Equality or Substance View. Natural law thinkers argue that equal rights must rest on the kind of being someone is, rather than on abilities that differ from one person to another.

Human beings possess a rational nature even when they cannot presently exercise rational abilities.

Natural Law and Abortion

Natural law arguments against abortion usually proceed through several connected claims:

  1. The unborn child is a distinct, living human organism from fertilization.
  2. Every human being possesses inherent worth because of his or her human nature.
  3. Human life is a basic good that should never be intentionally attacked.
  4. Induced abortion ordinarily involves intentionally causing the death of an unborn human being.
  5. Therefore, induced abortion is ordinarily morally wrong.

Under this view, abortion is wrong not because pregnancy is easy or because the mother’s interests do not matter. It is wrong because deliberately killing one human being cannot be used as the means of solving another person’s hardship.

Natural law ethics also recognizes serious responsibilities toward pregnant women, especially those facing poverty, medical complications, abandonment, abuse, or an unexpected pregnancy. Respecting unborn life does not remove society’s duty to protect and support the mother.

Deliberately killing one human being cannot be used as the means of solving another person’s hardship.

Intention and the Principle of Double Effect

Natural law ethics distinguishes between intending a child’s death and providing necessary medical treatment when the child’s death is foreseen but not intended.

Under the principle of double effect, a treatment with both a good effect and a harmful effect may sometimes be permissible when:

  1. The action is not inherently wrong.
  2. The harmful effect is not intended.
  3. The harmful effect is not used as the means of producing the good effect.
  4. There is a sufficiently serious reason for permitting the harmful effect.

For example, removing a ruptured fallopian tube during an ectopic pregnancy may be understood as treating a life-threatening medical condition. The child’s death is foreseen and deeply tragic, but it is not chosen as the means of saving the mother.

By contrast, directly injecting a substance into the child to stop the child’s heart would intentionally cause death and would not satisfy the principle.

Natural Law and Bodily Autonomy

Natural law thinkers agree that people normally possess strong authority over their bodies. However, bodily autonomy is not considered unlimited. Personal freedom must be exercised consistently with justice and the rights of others.

Pregnancy is also understood as a parental relationship rather than a relationship between strangers. Because parents have special responsibilities toward their dependent children, natural law thinkers generally reject the claim that an unborn child may be intentionally killed simply because the child depends on the mother’s body.

This response is especially relevant to Judith Jarvis Thomson’s Famous Violinist argument, which compares pregnancy to being involuntarily connected to an unrelated person. Natural law proponents argue that the comparison overlooks the parent-child relationship and the difference between refusing extraordinary assistance and intentionally killing someone.

Personal freedom must be exercised consistently with justice and the rights of others.

Natural Law and Civil Law

Natural law distinguishes morality from legislation. Not every immoral act must be prohibited by the government, and lawmakers may have to consider enforceability, social consequences, and the common good.

However, natural law thinkers usually regard the protection of innocent human life as a central responsibility of government. Because the unborn child is considered a member of the human family, laws permitting abortion are viewed as denying equal protection to an entire class of human beings.

This does not mean that every natural law thinker supports identical policies, penalties, or enforcement methods. They may disagree about how abortion laws should be structured while agreeing that the law should protect unborn human life.

Common Misunderstandings

MisunderstandingNatural-law response
“Natural law means everything natural is good.”Natural law concerns goods and moral principles discoverable through reason, not everything that happens in nature.
“It is only a Catholic religious belief.”Catholic thinkers greatly developed the tradition, but natural-law arguments appeal to human nature, reason, and objective goods rather than relying exclusively on revelation.
“It ignores the mother.”The mother’s life, health, dignity, and welfare are also basic human goods. Natural law rejects intentionally killing either patient.
“It requires preserving life at every cost.”It permits refusing excessively burdensome or disproportionate treatment. It distinguishes allowing death from intentionally causing death.

Major Thinkers

ThinkerContribution
AristotleDeveloped an account of human nature, virtue, reason, and flourishing that influenced later natural law thought
Thomas AquinasGave classical natural law its most influential philosophical and theological formulation
Germain GrisezHelped develop the New Natural Law Theory and applied it extensively to bioethics
John FinnisPresented a modern account of basic human goods, practical reason, law, and human rights
Joseph BoyleDeveloped natural law reasoning concerning intention, killing, and the principle of double effect
Robert P. GeorgeApplies natural law to human dignity, constitutional questions, abortion, marriage, and public policy
Patrick LeeApplies natural law and the substance view to abortion, personal identity, and human equality

Pro-Life Significance

Natural law provides a wider philosophical foundation for the pro-life position. It explains why human life is valuable, why all human beings deserve equal protection, why intentions matter, and why freedom must be directed by justice.

Its central claim is that basic human rights do not depend on whether others want us, recognize us, or consider us useful. They arise from the kind of beings we are.

Basic human rights do not depend on whether others want us, recognize us, or consider us useful. They arise from the kind of beings we are.