Thomas Aquinas

Who Was Thomas Aquinas?

Thomas Aquinas was an Italian Dominican friar, theologian, and philosopher who lived from approximately 1225 to 1274. He is regarded as one of the most influential thinkers in Western philosophy and Catholic theology.

Aquinas brought together Christian theology and the philosophy of Aristotle, developing a systematic account of God, human nature, morality, law, virtue, and political society. His best-known work is the Summa Theologiae.

The Catholic Church recognizes Aquinas as a saint and a Doctor of the Church, but his influence extends well beyond Catholic theology. His ideas remain important in philosophy, law, bioethics, and debates about human rights.

Faith and Reason

Aquinas believed that faith and reason cannot ultimately contradict each other because both truth and human reason come from God.

Some truths, such as the existence of objective moral duties, can be approached through ordinary human reasoning. Other truths depend on divine revelation. Natural law belongs primarily to the first category. Aquinas argued that people can recognize its basic principles even without knowing Christian theology.

This is why modern natural law arguments against abortion are not simply appeals to the Bible or Church authority. They can begin with publicly accessible facts about human biology, human nature, justice, and the protection owed to innocent human beings.

Natural Law

For Aquinas, natural law is the way rational creatures participate in the objective moral order. It consists of basic moral principles that human beings can recognize through reason.

Its first and most fundamental principle is:

“Good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided.”

More specific moral principles arise from natural human inclinations and goods, including:

  • Preserving human life
  • Forming families and caring for children
  • Seeking truth
  • Living in society
  • Acting rationally
  • Pursuing justice and the common good

Natural law does not mean that everything occurring in nature is morally good. Disease, violence, and death are natural occurrences, but they are not therefore goods to be pursued. Natural law concerns what fulfills human nature and how reason should direct human choices.

Human Nature and the Person

Aquinas understood the human person as a unity of body and soul. The body is not a disposable object inhabited by the “real person.” It is an essential part of who the person is.

The soul is the form of the body, meaning the principle that organizes and animates a living human being. A human soul includes the powers of nutrition, growth, sensation, thought, and free choice.

This understanding is important to contemporary abortion debates. Many capacity-based theories effectively separate the person from the living human organism, claiming that the person appears only when consciousness or self-awareness develops. Thomistic thinkers instead argue that the human being who later thinks and chooses is the same bodily individual who first existed as an embryo.

Human Life as a Basic Good

Aquinas regarded life as a fundamental human good. Human beings naturally seek to preserve their lives, and reason recognizes that innocent human life should not be intentionally destroyed.

Life is not merely useful because it allows someone to achieve other goals. It is good in itself and forms the basis on which other human goods can be pursued.

Modern natural law thinkers build upon this principle in arguing that intentionally killing an unborn child is wrong. The child’s life is valuable even before he or she can think, feel, communicate, or act independently.

Aquinas and Abortion

Aquinas did not write a complete treatment of abortion comparable to modern works of bioethics. When he discussed it, he treated abortion as morally wrong.

However, he followed Aristotle’s outdated biological theory of delayed ensoulment. Aquinas believed that the developing organism passed through vegetative and sensitive stages before becoming capable of receiving a rational human soul. As a result, he did not classify an early abortion as homicide in exactly the same sense as killing an “animated,” or rationally ensouled, fetus.

This distinction concerned the kind of offense he believed had occurred. It did not amount to approval of early abortion. Aquinas regarded deliberately interfering with human generation as seriously wrong, even when he did not classify the act as homicide.

Would Aquinas Place Ensoulment at Fertilization Today?

No one can say with certainty what Aquinas would conclude if he possessed modern scientific knowledge. It is reasonable, however, to recognize that his account of delayed ensoulment depended heavily on ancient embryology.

Aquinas and Aristotle did not know about:

  • Human egg cells
  • Chromosomes and DNA
  • The union of sperm and egg
  • The genetic identity established at fertilization
  • The embryo’s internally directed development
  • The continuity of one organism throughout prenatal development

Modern embryology shows that fertilization produces a distinct, living human organism that actively directs his or her own development. There is no later biological event at which a nonhuman entity becomes a human organism.

Many contemporary Thomistic philosophers therefore conclude that Aquinas’s basic philosophy of human nature fits better with immediate human existence at fertilization than with his medieval embryology.

It would nevertheless be inaccurate to claim that Aquinas himself explicitly taught that personal life begins at fertilization. His actual historical position should be acknowledged rather than rewritten.

The Principle of Double Effect

Aquinas is commonly credited with providing the foundation for the principle of double effect. In discussing self-defense, he observed that one action can have two effects: one that is intended and another that is foreseen but not intended.

Later natural law thinkers developed this reasoning into a framework for evaluating difficult medical situations. An action with a harmful secondary effect may sometimes be permissible when:

  1. The action itself is morally good or neutral.
  2. The harmful effect is not intended.
  3. The harmful effect is not used as the means of achieving the good effect.
  4. There is a proportionately serious reason for permitting the harm.

This principle is especially important in pro-life medical ethics. It explains why treating a pregnant woman’s life-threatening condition can be morally permissible even when the child’s death is foreseen, provided that the child is not intentionally killed as the means of treatment.

For example, removing a damaged fallopian tube during an ectopic pregnancy may result in the child’s death, but the act directly treats the dangerous medical condition. This differs morally from injecting the child with a drug for the purpose of causing death.

Intention and Moral Action

For Aquinas, judging an action requires examining more than its physical outcome. Three elements matter:

ElementMeaning
The objectWhat action is actually being chosen
The intentionWhat the person is trying to accomplish
The circumstancesThe surrounding facts, risks, and consequences

A good intention cannot make an inherently wrongful act good. Saving a woman from serious hardship may be a compassionate goal, but Aquinas’s moral framework would not permit intentionally killing an innocent human being as the means of accomplishing it.

At the same time, an action with a tragic side effect is not automatically equivalent to deliberately causing that effect. This distinction helps natural law ethics address difficult pregnancies without treating every fetal death as an abortion.

Natural Law and Civil Law

Aquinas did not believe that governments should prohibit every immoral act. Human law must be realistic, enforceable, and directed toward the common good. Some wrongs may be tolerated when attempting to prohibit them would cause greater disorder.

However, the protection of innocent life is among the law’s most basic responsibilities. An unjust law may possess legal force while failing to bind in conscience in the fullest moral sense.

This principle later influenced thinkers and reformers who argued that government authority must answer to a higher standard of justice. Martin Luther King Jr., for example, invoked Aquinas when distinguishing just laws from unjust laws.

For modern pro-life natural law thinkers, abortion laws are unjust when they exclude unborn human beings from the protection ordinarily given to innocent members of the human family.

Aquinas and Human Equality

Aquinas lived within a medieval society and did not formulate modern human rights language. Some of his political and social conclusions also reflect assumptions that modern readers rightly reject.

Nevertheless, his philosophy contributed important foundations for human equality:

  • Human beings share a common rational nature.
  • Human value is not created by government.
  • Moral truth is not determined entirely by social convention.
  • Human law must be evaluated according to justice.
  • Innocent life may not be intentionally attacked for another person’s benefit.
  • The common good must be more than the private advantage of the powerful.

Modern pro-life thinkers develop these principles into the argument that every human being deserves basic protection, regardless of size, age, ability, dependency, health, or location.

Influence on Modern Pro-Life Thought

Aquinas’s influence is especially visible in the work of John Finnis, Germain Grisez, Patrick Lee, Robert P. George, Christopher Kaczor, and other natural law philosophers.

His thought supports several central pro-life principles:

  1. Human morality is grounded in objective truth.
  2. Human life is a basic good.
  3. The person is a unity of body and soul.
  4. Basic dignity does not depend on presently exercisable abilities.
  5. Intentionally killing is morally different from foreseeing death as a side effect.
  6. Civil law should serve justice and protect vulnerable human beings.

Aquinas did not possess modern embryological knowledge, but the philosophical framework he developed remains one of the most important intellectual foundations of contemporary pro-life ethics.

Major Works

WorkImportance
Summa TheologiaeAquinas’s largest systematic treatment of theology, morality, virtue, law, and human action
Summa Contra GentilesExplores philosophical and theological truths through reasoned argument
Commentary on Aristotle’s Nicomachean EthicsExamines virtue, practical wisdom, happiness, and moral action
On Being and EssencePresents Aquinas’s account of existence, essence, and the nature of beings
Disputed Questions on TruthAddresses truth, knowledge, conscience, freedom, and the human mind