Eileen McDonagh

Who Is Eileen McDonagh?

Eileen McDonagh is an American political scientist and professor emerita at Northeastern University. She received her doctorate in government from Harvard University and has written extensively about women, political citizenship, equality, and American law.

Her main contribution to the abortion debate is her 1996 book, Breaking the Abortion Deadlock: From Choice to Consent. McDonagh presents one of the strongest versions of the bodily autonomy argument.

Rather than focusing primarily on whether the fetus is a person, she asks whether a woman has consented to the physical relationship created by pregnancy.

From Choice to Consent

McDonagh argues that the language of “choice” does not adequately explain abortion rights. Choice can sound like a personal preference that must be balanced against the government’s interest in protecting fetal life.

She instead uses the language of consent. A person ordinarily has the right to decide whether another individual may enter, remain inside, or use his or her body.

Under this view, the central question is not simply:

What may a woman choose to do with her body?

It is:

Has she consented to what the fetus is doing to her body?

McDonagh believes this change strengthens the case for abortion because bodily consent is already recognized as central in areas such as sex, medical treatment, physical contact, and organ donation.

Consent to Sex Is Not Consent to Pregnancy

McDonagh rejects the argument that voluntarily engaging in sex automatically amounts to consenting to pregnancy.

She distinguishes among:

  • Consent to sexual intercourse
  • Acceptance that pregnancy is a possible result
  • Consent to continue an actual pregnancy

Knowing that one action carries a risk does not ordinarily eliminate the right to respond if that risk occurs. A driver who knows that an accident is possible does not consent to being denied medical treatment after a collision.

McDonagh therefore argues that even when pregnancy results from voluntary sex, the woman retains the right to refuse the fetus’s continued use of her body.

Pregnancy as Bodily Intrusion

McDonagh describes pregnancy as an active physical process that produces extensive changes in the woman’s body. The embryo implants in the uterine lining, the placenta develops, and the pregnancy redirects blood flow, oxygen, nutrients, hormones, and organ function.

When the pregnancy is wanted, the woman consents to these changes and accepts the relationship.

When it is unwanted, McDonagh argues that the same biological processes constitute a nonconsensual bodily intrusion. The pregnancy may be medically normal, but normality does not establish consent.

In her theory, the relevant question is not whether the fetus acts consciously or maliciously. The fetus can impose physical effects without possessing moral responsibility, just as an innocent or unconscious person can still create a physical threat.

The Fetus as an Innocent Aggressor

McDonagh sometimes describes the fetus as an aggressor because the fetus’s presence and biological activity impose pregnancy on the woman’s body.

She does not mean that the fetus possesses criminal intent or deliberately chooses to attack the woman. Her argument relies on the concept of an innocent aggressor or innocent threat, someone who creates a serious bodily imposition without being morally guilty.

McDonagh argues that self-defense may be justified against an innocent threat when resisting the threat is necessary to protect bodily integrity. The threat’s lack of malicious intent does not require the threatened person to surrender control of her body.

Abortion as Self-Defense

McDonagh goes beyond Judith Jarvis Thomson’s claim that abortion can be understood as withdrawing bodily assistance.

She argues that an unwanted pregnancy itself violates the woman’s bodily integrity. Abortion may therefore be understood as defensive force used to stop that violation.

Because removing the fetus before viability results in death, McDonagh maintains that lethal force may be justified when it is the only available way to end the unwanted bodily occupation.

Her defense of abortion is therefore stronger than a simple right to refuse assistance. It treats abortion as protection against an ongoing physical intrusion.

The Role of Government

McDonagh argues that government does more than refrain from interfering with abortion. The state ordinarily protects people against nonconsensual bodily intrusion by providing police, courts, medical services, and other forms of assistance.

If pregnancy is treated as an unwanted bodily intrusion, she argues that equal protection may require the government to help women end it. This could include providing access to abortion and, in some circumstances, public funding.

Her constitutional argument draws upon both the Due Process Clause and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

American courts never adopted McDonagh’s complete theory. Furthermore, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization held that the federal Constitution does not confer a right to abortion. Her consent model remains a philosophical and legal proposal rather than controlling constitutional law.

How Her View Differs From Other Bodily Autonomy Arguments

ThinkerCentral argument
Judith Jarvis ThomsonA right to life does not necessarily include a right to use another person’s body
David BooninEven a fetal person may be removed because people cannot ordinarily be compelled to provide bodily support
Eileen McDonaghAn unwanted fetus is not merely receiving assistance but imposing a nonconsensual bodily intrusion that may be resisted
Pro-life positionPregnancy is a parent-child relationship, and bodily autonomy does not include a right to intentionally kill a dependent child

McDonagh therefore frames abortion more explicitly as self-defense, while Thomson and Boonin more commonly compare it to withdrawing assistance.

The Pro-Life Response

The Child Is Not an Attacker

The most fundamental objection is that an unborn child is not attacking the mother.

The child does not choose to enter the uterus, initiate conception, or impose dependency. He or she comes into existence through reproduction and develops according to the normal biological process of human life.

The embryo participates biologically in implantation, but so does the mother’s reproductive system. Describing this process as fetal aggression turns a natural relationship of dependency into the language of assault.

A person may cause physical effects without being morally guilty, but not every unwanted physical effect constitutes an unjust attack that permits lethal force.

Pregnancy Is a Parent-Child Relationship

McDonagh analyzes pregnancy largely through rules governing bodily interactions between independent individuals. Pro-life thinkers argue that this overlooks the relationship between parent and child.

Parents have duties toward their dependent children that they do not have toward strangers. A newborn also makes extensive demands on a parent’s body, time, sleep, labor, and resources. The fact that these burdens were not individually chosen does not create a right to kill or abandon the child.

Pregnancy is the earliest and most physically intimate form of the care all human beings require at that stage of development.

Lack of Consent Does Not Erase Responsibility

Consent is essential in sexual relationships, medical treatment, and many interactions between adults. It cannot explain every moral responsibility, however.

Children cannot lose their right to basic care simply because their parents did not consent to their existence or later withdraw consent to parenting. Some duties arise from relationships and dependency rather than from continuing contractual agreement.

Pro-life critics therefore argue that a woman’s understandable unwillingness to remain pregnant does not transform her child into an unlawful intruder.

Foreseeable Risk Can Create Obligations

Consent to sex is not identical to a desire for pregnancy. However, consensual sex is the voluntary act through which children naturally come into existence.

People sometimes acquire responsibilities through actions whose results they did not intend. A person who creates a vulnerable dependent cannot necessarily end that responsibility by saying the result was unwanted.

This response does not apply in the same way to rape, where the woman did not voluntarily accept the reproductive act. In that case, the pro-life position rests more directly on the child’s humanity and innocence. The father’s crime does not change the identity or value of the child conceived.

Self-Defense Must Be Proportionate

Self-defense generally requires a sufficiently serious threat and a proportionate response. Ordinary pregnancy involves real burdens and medical risks, but it does not ordinarily threaten death or catastrophic injury.

McDonagh’s argument permits lethal force against a fetus even during a medically normal pregnancy because the pregnancy lacks continuing consent. Pro-life critics argue that this expands self-defense far beyond its usual limits.

Unwanted bodily contact does not always justify killing the person responsible, especially when that person is innocent, dependent, and unable to leave without dying.

Abortion Attacks the Child’s Body

McDonagh emphasizes the woman’s bodily integrity but gives less attention to what abortion does to the fetus’s body.

Medication abortion causes the embryo or fetus to be detached and expelled. Surgical abortion uses suction or instruments to remove the child, often causing bodily dismemberment in the process.

The unborn child also has bodily integrity. The bodily autonomy of one human being does not automatically authorize lethal violence against the body of another.

The Mother and Child Are Not Enemies

McDonagh’s theory portrays pregnancy as a conflict between an intruder and the person resisting that intrusion.

Pro-life ethics recognizes that the interests of mother and child can sometimes conflict, especially during medical emergencies. However, it begins with the understanding that both are patients and members of the human family.

The goal should be to protect and support both whenever possible, not to classify the weaker and completely dependent party as an aggressor.

Difficult and Life-Threatening Pregnancies

The pro-life response does not require a woman to accept certain death or prohibit physicians from treating a medical emergency.

Doctors may treat conditions such as ectopic pregnancy, severe infection, cancer, or placental complications, even when the child’s death cannot be prevented. Early delivery may also be necessary when continuing the pregnancy presents a grave danger.

The moral distinction concerns whether the treatment addresses a dangerous medical condition or intentionally kills the child as the means of ending the danger.

McDonagh’s theory does not require a life-threatening condition. For her, the absence of consent can itself justify abortion during an otherwise medically normal pregnancy. This is where her view most sharply conflicts with the pro-life position.

Criticism From Within the Abortion-Rights Movement

McDonagh’s theory has also received criticism from scholars who support legal abortion.

Some question whether a fetus can coherently be treated as an aggressor with enough agency to create a legally wrongful intrusion while being denied the protections that would ordinarily accompany personhood.

Others argue that describing pregnancy as an attack creates an unnecessarily hostile picture of the relationship between women and their unborn children. It may also reduce the complicated experiences of pregnancy and abortion to a model borrowed from assault and self-defense.

McDonagh’s supporters respond that legal responsibility does not require malicious intent and that acknowledging the physical demands of pregnancy is necessary to take women’s bodily rights seriously.

Why She Matters

McDonagh developed one of the clearest and most aggressive forms of the bodily autonomy argument. She does not merely claim that women should be free to make private choices. She argues that unwanted pregnancy is a nonconsensual use of the body and that government should actively help women end it.

Her theory exposes a central disagreement in the abortion debate:

Is an unborn child an unwanted bodily intruder, or a dependent child toward whom parental obligations already exist?

The answer depends not only on consent, but also on how we understand reproduction, parenthood, bodily rights, self-defense, and the moral status of the unborn.

Major Works

WorkImportance
Breaking the Abortion Deadlock: From Choice to ConsentDevelops McDonagh’s consent-based and self-defense argument for abortion
“The Next Step After Roe”Applies fundamental-rights and equal-protection arguments to abortion restrictions
“Good, Bad, and Captive Samaritans”Adds pregnancy and continuing consent to bodily autonomy arguments
The Motherless StateExamines women’s political leadership and American democracy
Playing With the BoysCoauthored with Laura Pappano, arguing against sex separation in sports