Consequentialism and Utilitarianism

What Are Consequentialism and Utilitarianism?

Consequentialism is the view that the morality of an action depends on its consequences. An action is right if it produces the best available outcome and wrong if another action would produce a better one.

Utilitarianism is the best known form of consequentialism. It holds that the best outcome is the one that maximizes overall well being while minimizing suffering.

The terms are related but not interchangeable:

  • Every utilitarian theory is consequentialist.
  • Not every consequentialist theory is utilitarian.
  • Consequentialists may disagree about which consequences count as good.
  • Utilitarians generally focus on welfare, happiness, preferences, or the reduction of suffering.

Classical utilitarianism is associated primarily with Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Bentham emphasized pleasure and pain. Mill described morally right actions as those that promote happiness for everyone affected, not merely the person acting.

The Basic Principle

A simplified utilitarian argument proceeds as follows:

  1. Morality should promote well being and reduce suffering.
  2. Each individual’s welfare should receive equal consideration.
  3. The morally right action is the available action that produces the greatest net benefit for everyone affected.

Utilitarianism is impartial. A person should not count his or her own happiness as inherently more important than the equal happiness of someone else.

This does not necessarily mean producing happiness for the greatest number of people. A policy benefiting a majority could still be wrong if the harm imposed on a minority outweighs the benefits.

Different Forms

Act Utilitarianism

Act utilitarianism evaluates each individual action by its expected consequences.

Under this view, an abortion would be evaluated by comparing its likely results with the likely results of continuing the pregnancy.

Rule Utilitarianism

Rule utilitarianism asks which general rules would produce the best consequences if widely accepted.

Instead of evaluating only one abortion, it might ask what rules concerning abortion, parental duties, medical care, and protection of human life would create the best society over time.

Rule consequentialism developed partly because judging every action separately can appear to justify conduct that violates trust, justice, or individual rights.

Preference Utilitarianism

Preference utilitarianism evaluates actions according to how well they satisfy the preferences or interests of those affected.

This raises an important abortion question: can a fetus have preferences or interests before becoming conscious?

Some preference utilitarians answer no. Others argue that an individual can have an interest in continued life even without presently understanding or expressing that interest.

Applying Utilitarianism to Abortion

A utilitarian analysis attempts to consider every foreseeable benefit and harm associated with abortion or continued pregnancy.

These may include:

  • The woman’s health and welfare
  • The burdens of pregnancy and childbirth
  • The desires of the mother and father
  • The child’s possible future welfare
  • Effects on siblings and other family members
  • Financial and social circumstances
  • The availability of adoption and material support
  • The physical or psychological effects of abortion
  • Broader effects on medical ethics, families, and society

Unlike theories based on human rights or intrinsic dignity, utilitarianism does not begin by asking whether abortion directly violates an inviolable right. It asks which available choice produces the best overall consequences.

The answer depends heavily on whose welfare counts, how heavily it counts, and how uncertain future outcomes are evaluated.

Sentience and Interests

Some utilitarian arguments give moral consideration primarily to sentient beings because sentient beings can experience pleasure and pain.

Before the fetus becomes sentient, it cannot consciously experience an abortion or express preferences. A utilitarian may therefore assign the early fetus little or no present welfare to be weighed against the interests of the pregnant woman.

After sentience develops, fetal pain and other experiences may enter the calculation. Even then, a philosopher may distinguish between experiencing pain and possessing self awareness or future directed preferences.

Peter Singer, a prominent contemporary utilitarian, argues that belonging to the human species does not by itself determine moral status. His approach emphasizes sentience, interests, rationality, self awareness, and preferences rather than biological humanity alone. He consequently supports broad abortion access, including infanticide, arguing that sometimes infants might not possess adequate levels of these characteristics to obtain moral protections.

The Value of the Child’s Future

Utilitarians disagree about how to evaluate the future the unborn child might have experienced.

One approach counts the future happiness the child would probably enjoy. Abortion may then represent a substantial loss of future well being.

Another approach counts only the interests of people who already exist independently of the decision. Under that approach, creating an additional happy person may not be morally required, while harming an existing person remains morally significant.

This disagreement belongs to population ethics, which examines whether morality should maximize total welfare, average welfare, or the welfare of people who already exist. Different versions can produce different conclusions about abortion.

Consequentialism therefore does not automatically produce a pro-choice conclusion. If the unborn child’s future welfare is fully counted, abortion may appear to cause the greatest loss. If the fetus has little present moral standing and its possible future is not counted, the woman’s interests may dominate the calculation.

The Pro-Life Response

Human Worth Cannot Depend on a Calculation

The central pro-life objection is that human beings possess inherent worth that cannot be created or removed by a calculation of social benefit.

If killing is wrong only when it reduces overall welfare, an innocent person could theoretically be killed whenever doing so produced sufficiently beneficial consequences for others.

The pro-life position instead holds that certain acts are wrong because they violate the basic rights of an individual, even when other people might benefit.

Imagine that five patients will die without organ transplants. A healthy person arrives at the hospital whose organs could save all five. If only the total outcome mattered, killing that innocent person and distributing the organs might appear justified because five lives would be saved at the cost of one. The example illustrates how maximizing overall welfare can conflict with the individual’s right not to be intentionally killed.

Aggregate Welfare Can Conceal Individual Harm

Utilitarian reasoning combines benefits and harms across different people. This can obscure who experiences the harm.

Many people might receive smaller benefits from an abortion, but the unborn child loses his or her entire life. Those benefits do not occur within the same individual who suffers the loss.

From the pro-life perspective, the child cannot be treated merely as one variable in a calculation. The child is a distinct human being whose life may not be intentionally taken for the benefit of others.

Many people might receive smaller benefits from an abortion, but the unborn child loses his or her entire life.

The Fetus Must Be Included

A utilitarian defense of abortion often depends on assigning the fetus little moral weight before sentience or self-awareness.

The pro-life response is that this assumes a disputed theory of moral status. If the embryo is an individual human organism with a valuable future, excluding that future from the calculation prejudges the central issue.

The inability to feel pain does not normally make it permissible to kill a sleeping, unconscious, or anesthetized human being. The wrongness of killing cannot be reduced entirely to the pain experienced during death.

Consequences Are Difficult to Predict

Utilitarian judgments require comparisons between possible futures that cannot be known with certainty.

A difficult pregnancy may result in a deeply valuable life. A child expected to experience disability or hardship may still experience love, relationships, achievement, and joy. Parents may later evaluate circumstances differently than they did during a crisis.

These uncertainties make irreversible decisions about life especially dangerous. A mistaken prediction after birth can be reconsidered. An abortion cannot be reversed.

Utilitarian judgments require comparisons between possible futures that cannot be known with certainty.

Social Consequences Also Matter

Even within consequentialist reasoning, abortion must be evaluated beyond its immediate benefits.

A complete analysis might consider:

  • The normalization of intentionally ending dependent human life
  • Pressure to abort children with disabilities
  • Sex selective abortion
  • Reduced expectations of paternal responsibility
  • The effects of abortion on medical practice
  • The possibility that social support could relieve the burdens used to justify abortion
  • The loss of every future good the child might have experienced or contributed

These considerations do not by themselves prove the pro-life position, but they show that the consequences of abortion extend beyond “just ending a pregnancy”.

Good Consequences Do Not Justify Every Means

Pro-life ethics can recognize consequences as morally important without treating them as the sole measure of right and wrong.

Consequences matter when determining how to help a pregnant woman, protect her health, support her family, and respond to medical complications. They do not justify intentionally killing an innocent human being.

The pro-life position therefore places moral limits on which means may be used to pursue otherwise desirable outcomes.

Consequentialism Compared With Other Views

ViewPrimary moral question
ConsequentialismWhich action will produce the best overall results?
UtilitarianismWhich action will maximize overall well being?
Natural Law EthicsWhich action respects human nature and fundamental human goods?
Virtue EthicsWhat would a just and virtuous person do?
Human Equality ViewDoes the action respect the equal dignity of every human being?
Rights Based EthicsDoes the action violate an individual’s fundamental rights?

Consequentialism emphasizes outcomes. The other views maintain that the nature of an act, the character of the person acting, or the rights of the individuals involved may place limits on what may be done even to achieve good results.

Strengths and Limitations

Consequentialism draws attention to real human needs and discourages moral reasoning that ignores foreseeable suffering. It encourages consideration of everyone affected rather than focusing only on intentions.

Its central limitation is that consequences alone may not adequately protect individuals. Outcomes are uncertain, different kinds of harm are difficult to compare, and aggregate benefits can be used to justify severe injustice toward a minority.

In abortion ethics, the decisive issue becomes whether the unborn child’s life and future are included in the calculation. If they are excluded, abortion may appear beneficial. If they receive the same moral consideration as the lives of other human beings, abortion creates an overwhelming loss that smaller benefits cannot easily outweigh.

If the unborn receive the same moral consideration as the lives of other human beings, abortion creates an overwhelming loss that smaller benefits cannot easily outweigh.

Why Consequentialism and Utilitarianism Matter

Consequentialist arguments appear throughout the abortion debate, even when the terminology is not used.

Claims that abortion reduces poverty, prevents suffering, protects existing families, or improves social outcomes are consequentialist claims. So are pro-life arguments concerning the child’s lost future, discrimination against disability, harm to women, and the long-term effects of treating some human lives as disposable.

The fundamental disagreement is not whether consequences matter. It is whether consequences are the final measure of morality and whether any anticipated benefit can justify intentionally ending an innocent human life.

Major Thinkers

ThinkerContribution
Jeremy BenthamDeveloped classical utilitarianism around pleasure, pain, and the principle of utility
John Stuart MillDefended the greatest happiness principle and distinguished higher from lower forms of pleasure
Henry SidgwickSystematized classical utilitarian ethics in The Methods of Ethics
R. M. HareDeveloped a form of preference utilitarianism and applied it to practical moral questions
Peter SingerApplies utilitarian reasoning to abortion, animal ethics, poverty, and euthanasia
Derek ParfitExamined consequentialism, personal identity, and population ethics