Fetal homicide laws, sometimes called unborn victims of violence laws, allow someone to be prosecuted for causing the death of an unborn child while committing a crime against a pregnant woman. Depending on the law and circumstances, the offense may be called murder, manslaughter, feticide, or another form of criminal homicide.
These laws vary by jurisdiction. Some protect an unborn child from fertilization or at any stage of development, while others apply only after a particular developmental point. Some require the offender to know about the pregnancy or intend to harm the child, but others do not.
Nonsensically, most fetal homicide laws, including The Unborn Victims of Violence Act, specifically exclude abortion and acts committed by the pregnant woman against her own unborn child. Although depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances, prosecutors have sometimes used other laws involving controlled substances, child neglect, or harm discovered after birth. Those are separate from fetal homicide laws.
Examples of Application
| Case | What happened | How the law was applied |
|---|---|---|
| Scott Peterson, California | Peterson was convicted of killing his pregnant wife, Laci, and their unborn son, Conner. | He was convicted of first-degree murder for Laci’s death and second-degree murder for Conner’s death. California law recognized Conner as a separate homicide victim. |
| State v. Merrill, Minnesota | Dale Merrill killed Gail Anderson, who was in the earliest weeks of pregnancy, along with her approximately 28-day-old embryo. | Merrill pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder. The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled that the fetal homicide law could apply before viability and even if the offender did not know the woman was pregnant. |
| Amber Waterman, federal prosecution | Waterman kidnapped and killed Ashley Bush, who was 31 weeks pregnant, in an attempt to take her unborn daughter, Valkyrie. | She pleaded guilty to kidnapping resulting in death and causing the death of a child in utero. She received two consecutive life sentences without parole. |
| Deundrea Holloway, Illinois | Holloway killed Liese Dodd and her unborn daughter in 2022. | He pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and intentional homicide of an unborn child. He received a separate 20-year sentence for the unborn child’s death. |
Fetal homicide laws are significant to the abortion debate because they recognize that a criminal attack can produce two victims: the pregnant woman and her unborn child. Pro-life advocates argue that this reflects the biological reality that the unborn child is a distinct human organism and exposes an inconsistency in laws that protect the child from outside violence while permitting abortion.
These laws do not necessarily grant unborn children full legal personhood as legislatures can recognize an unborn child as a victim for a limited purpose while expressly excluding abortion, which pro-life advocates would argue is senseless.