Personhood

Personhood is the status of being a person—an individual who possesses moral worth and is owed basic respect and protection. In ordinary language, a person is a human individual. In philosophy and law, however, the term can carry more specific and sometimes disputed meanings.

It is helpful to distinguish three related questions:

  • Biological: Is the being a living human organism?
  • Moral: Does that human being possess inherent value and basic rights?
  • Legal: Does the law officially recognize that being as a person with enforceable rights?

In the abortion debate, the biological identity of the embryo or fetus as a living human organism is distinct from the philosophical question of personhood. The pro-life position holds that every human being is a person from fertilization and are therefore deserving of dignity and protection.

“Believing that personhood begins at any other point other than fertilization is arbitrary and, therefore, dangerous to the definition of human rights.”

Some abortion-rights arguments separate being biologically human from being a person. They connect personhood to Immediately Exercisable Capacity such as consciousness, self-awareness, reasoning, communication, sentience, or independence. Under these views, an unborn human may acquire personhood only after reaching a particular developmental threshold. A difficulty with capacity-based definitions is that newborns, people with profound cognitive disabilities, and patients who are temporarily unconscious may not presently exercise those abilities either. Such theories must therefore explain why these humans retain rights while prenatal humans do not.

Legal personhood means recognition as a rights-bearing person under the law. In Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court concluded that the word “person” in the Fourteenth Amendment did not include the unborn. Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization later overturned Roe’s constitutional right to abortion, but it did not rule that unborn human beings are Fourteenth Amendment persons. Their federal constitutional status therefore remains unresolved, although states may protect unborn life through their own laws.

“Biology can establish what an embryo or fetus is; the personhood debate concerns how that human being ought to be valued and treated.”