The Case
In September 2024, an unnamed North Texas woman learned that she was pregnant by her then-boyfriend, Justin Anthony Banta. According to investigators, Banta offered to pay for an abortion and suggested ordering abortion pills online. The woman told him that she wanted to continue the pregnancy.
On October 17, when she was approximately six weeks pregnant, an ultrasound reportedly showed that her unborn child had a strong heartbeat, normal vital signs, and appeared healthy. Later that day, she met Banta at a coffee shop in Tarrant County.
According to a Texas Rangers affidavit, Banta secretly placed mifepristone, the first drug commonly used in a medication abortion, into cookies and a beverage that he gave her. The woman did not know about or consent to receiving the drug.
The following day, she experienced extreme fatigue and heavy bleeding. She sought emergency medical treatment and lost the child on October 19. Investigators reviewed her medical records as part of the case.
Alleged Destruction of Evidence
During the investigation, authorities collected Banta’s cellphone. The Parker County Sheriff’s Office alleges that Banta, who worked in information technology for the U.S. Department of Justice, remotely accessed the phone and reset it, deleting evidence investigators considered important to the case.
Criminal Case
Banta was arrested in June 2025 on allegations involving attempted capital murder and tampering with physical evidence. Some official statements and news reports referred to the principal allegation simply as capital murder.
He posted a $500,000 bond and was released. His attorney has denied the allegations, maintained that Banta is innocent, and argued that investigators lack sufficient evidence for a conviction.
As of September 2026, no conviction or final resolution has been publicly reported.
Why the Case Is Significant
The Banta case is especially important because Texas authorities treated the death of the unborn child as a potential homicide rather than only as an assault against the mother. Texas law generally recognizes an unborn child at any stage of development as an individual for purposes of its homicide laws, while exempting lawful medical care and actions taken by the pregnant woman herself.
The case also illustrates how abortion drugs obtained online may be used for reproductive abuse.