Scott Peterson

On Christmas Eve 2002, 27-year-old Laci Peterson disappeared from her home in Modesto, California. She was approximately eight months pregnant with a son whom she and her husband, Scott Peterson, had named Conner. Her disappearance led to an extensive search and drew national attention.

In April 2003, the remains of Laci and Conner were discovered separately along the shoreline of San Francisco Bay, near the area where Scott said he had gone fishing on the day she disappeared. Prosecutors argued that Scott had murdered Laci and disposed of her body in the bay. Their case relied largely on circumstantial evidence, including his extramarital affair, false statements, suspicious behavior, and connection to the location where the bodies were found.

In 2004, a jury convicted Scott Peterson of first-degree murder for Laci’s death and second-degree murder for Conner’s death. Under California law, Conner was recognized as a separate homicide victim. Scott was initially sentenced to death. In 2020, the California Supreme Court overturned his death sentence because of errors in selecting the penalty-phase jury, but it upheld both murder convictions. He was resentenced in 2021 to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

Scott has consistently maintained his innocence and continues to challenge his convictions. The Los Angeles Innocence Project began representing him in 2024 and has pursued additional evidence and testing. A California judge rejected his latest request to overturn the convictions in April 2026, although further appeals have been pursued. His two murder convictions remain in effect.

Scott Peterson received life in prison for the murder of his unborn child, yet abortion is permitted.

Significance to the Pro-Life Debate

The case brought national attention to the fact that violence against a pregnant woman can claim two distinct lives. Although fetal homicide protections existed in California before the murders, the case helped build public support for the Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2004, officially nicknamed “Laci and Conner’s Law.”

The federal law recognizes an unborn child as a separate victim when injured or killed during certain federal crimes. It applies at any stage of development but nonsensically excludes consensual abortion.

For pro-life advocates, the Peterson case exposes a major legal inconsistency. Conner’s death was treated as the murder of a separate victim because his mother wanted him, while an unborn child at the same stage of development may legally be killed through abortion. The child’s biological identity does not change according to whether the pregnancy is wanted, even though the law treats the two situations differently.