Who Was Aristotle?
Aristotle was an ancient Greek philosopher who lived from 384 to 322 BC. He studied under Plato, later tutored Alexander the Great, and founded his own school in Athens called the Lyceum.
Aristotle wrote about logic, biology, politics, ethics, metaphysics, psychology, and many other subjects. His work profoundly influenced Western philosophy, particularly the thought of Thomas Aquinas and the later natural-law tradition.
Unlike some philosophers who begin morality with rules or individual rights, Aristotle begins by asking what kind of life allows a human being to flourish.
Human Flourishing
Aristotle believed that every deliberate action aims at some perceived good. The highest human good is eudaimonia, commonly translated as happiness, well-being, or human flourishing.
Eudaimonia does not simply mean feeling happy. It means living well as a complete human being over the course of one’s life. Because human beings are rational and social by nature, flourishing requires the proper development of reason, character, relationships, and participation in a community.
For Aristotle, morality is therefore connected to human nature. To understand how people should live, we must first understand what human beings are and what allows them to fulfill their nature.
Virtue Ethics
Aristotle is one of the foundational thinkers behind virtue ethics. Rather than asking only, “What rule should I follow?” he asks, “What kind of person should I become?”
A virtue is a stable habit that allows someone to think, feel, and act well. Aristotle identifies virtues such as:
- Courage
- Justice
- Temperance
- Generosity
- Honesty
- Friendship
- Practical wisdom
Virtue generally involves finding the reasonable course between harmful extremes. Courage, for example, lies between cowardice and recklessness. This does not mean that every action has a morally acceptable middle. Some actions may be wrong in themselves.
Practical wisdom, or phronesis, is the ability to recognize what a good person should do in a particular situation. Moral maturity requires more than memorizing rules. It requires forming one’s character so that reason and desire are directed toward what is genuinely good.
Human Nature and Natural Law
Aristotle did not develop natural-law theory in the complete form later associated with Aquinas. Scholars debate whether he should be classified as a natural-law philosopher at all.
Nevertheless, several Aristotelian ideas became essential to the natural-law tradition:
- Human beings possess a definite nature.
- Certain goods objectively fulfill that nature.
- Reason can identify those goods.
- Human actions should be evaluated according to whether they promote genuine flourishing.
- Political communities should pursue justice and the common good.
- Human laws can be judged by standards higher than government authority or social custom.
Aquinas later combined these ideas with Christian theology and developed a more systematic account of natural law.
The Soul and the Body
Aristotle rejected the idea that the soul is simply a separate object temporarily inhabiting the body. He understood the soul as the form of a living body, meaning the organizing principle that makes a living thing the kind of being it is.
He described different powers of life:
| Power | What it includes |
|---|---|
| Vegetative | Nutrition, growth, and reproduction |
| Sensitive | Perception, appetite, pleasure, pain, and movement |
| Rational | Thought, judgment, and deliberate choice |
Plants possess vegetative powers. Animals possess vegetative and sensitive powers. Human beings possess all three, including the distinctive capacity for rational thought.
This understanding of the unity of body and soul later influenced natural-law arguments that the human person is a bodily being rather than a mind using a disposable body.
Aristotle’s Embryology
Aristotle was one of the earliest thinkers to study embryonic development systematically. He observed developing animal embryos and argued that their parts appear progressively rather than existing fully formed from the beginning.
However, he worked without modern knowledge of cells, genetics, fertilization, or DNA. He believed that the male supplied the active formative principle while the female supplied the material. He also associated different stages of development with vegetative, sensitive, and rational forms of life.
These scientific theories are now obsolete. Modern embryology shows that fertilization produces a new, genetically distinct, self-directed human organism. The embryo is not unorganized matter awaiting an external principle that will make it human. The embryo is already actively directing his or her own development.
Aristotle’s View of Abortion
Aristotle was not pro-life in the modern sense. In Politics, he proposed abortion as a means of limiting population when couples exceeded the number of children permitted by the state. He stated that abortion should occur before the developing child had acquired “sensation and life.”
He also supported refusing to rear children born with disabilities, a position directly opposed to the modern pro-life belief that every human being possesses equal dignity regardless of health or ability.
Aristotle’s views reflected his ancient political culture, limited embryological knowledge, and belief that the interests of the city could take priority over vulnerable individuals. They should not be confused with the later natural-law teaching that every human being has equal moral worth.
Did Aristotle Believe Life Began Later?
Aristotle recognized biological development within the womb, but he did not possess the scientific knowledge needed to identify fertilization as the beginning of a new organism. His theory treated the embryo as acquiring different life powers in stages.
Later thinkers sometimes used Aristotelian biology to support theories of delayed ensoulment, under which the rational soul appeared only after the body had developed sufficiently.
This history is sometimes used to argue that opposition to abortion at fertilization is a recent religious invention. That conclusion does not follow. Aristotle’s developmental timetable depended partly on ancient biological assumptions that have since been replaced. Modern pro-life arguments begin with the scientific finding that a new human organism comes into existence at fertilization and then ask what moral protection that organism deserves.
A philosopher’s moral reasoning may remain influential even when the scientific information on which some of his particular conclusions depended has been corrected.
Aristotle’s Influence on Pro-Life Thought
Modern pro-life philosophers draw on Aristotle primarily for his understanding of human nature, bodily existence, objective goods, virtue, and flourishing. They do not adopt all of his conclusions.
His influence can be seen in several pro-life ideas:
- Human beings have an objective nature. Human value is not created entirely by preference, social recognition, or government decree.
- The human person is a bodily being. A person is not merely a conscious mind separate from the living human organism.
- Abilities develop from what a being already is. A human embryo develops rational abilities because the embryo is already a human organism with an active capacity for human development.
- Morality concerns character and flourishing. Pregnancy and abortion should be considered in relation to justice, responsibility, compassion, parenthood, and respect for human life.
- Law should serve the common good. Political authority should be evaluated according to whether it promotes justice and protects the members of the community.
Where Pro-Life Thought Departs from Aristotle
Aristotle’s philosophy contains important insights, but the pro-life position rejects his unequal treatment of human beings.
| Aristotle’s position | Modern pro-life response |
|---|---|
| Moral and political standing was connected partly to development, citizenship, sex, and social position | Basic human rights belong equally to every human being |
| Abortion could be used for state population control before sensation | The state may not intentionally kill innocent human beings for social planning |
| Children with disabilities could be denied protection | Disability never removes a human being’s dignity or right to life |
| Embryology was based on limited observation and mistaken reproductive theories | Modern embryology identifies fertilization as the beginning of a new human organism |
| The community could subordinate vulnerable individuals to its preferred social order | The common good must include and protect its weakest members |
Why He Matters to the Abortion Debate
Aristotle matters because many major ideas in natural law and virtue ethics developed partly from his philosophy. He teaches that morality is connected to objective human goods and that freedom should be directed toward genuine flourishing.
At the same time, his treatment of abortion and disabled children demonstrates why an appeal to “nature” or “the common good” is insufficient unless it is joined to a firm principle of equal human dignity.
Modern pro-life thought can therefore draw from Aristotle’s account of human nature and virtue while rejecting conclusions that deny protection to human beings because of age, development, disability, or social usefulness.
Major Works
| Work | Importance |
|---|---|
| Nicomachean Ethics | Develops Aristotle’s account of virtue, practical wisdom, and human flourishing |
| Politics | Examines government, citizenship, family, education, law, and the common good |
| On the Soul | Explores life, perception, thought, and the relationship between soul and body |
| Generation of Animals | Presents Aristotle’s biological theories about reproduction and embryonic development |
| Metaphysics | Examines being, substance, causation, form, and matter |