David Boonin

Who Is David Boonin?

David Boonin is an American philosopher and professor at the University of Colorado Boulder. His work focuses on applied ethics, moral theory, abortion, punishment, race, sexual ethics, and public policy.

Boonin is one of the most systematic contemporary philosophical defenders of abortion. His two most important books on the subject are A Defense of Abortion and Beyond Roe: Why Abortion Should Be Legal Even if the Fetus Is a Person.

His defense has two separate parts:

  1. The early fetus does not yet possess a right to life.
  2. Even if the fetus is a person with a right to life, abortion may still be permissible because that right does not include a right to use the woman’s body.

Either argument, if successful, would support abortion independently of the other.

The Desire-Based Right to Life

Boonin argues that the right to life is connected to desires. Killing someone is especially wrong because it frustrates that individual’s desire to continue living and the future-directed interests connected to that desire.

A person does not need to be actively thinking, “I want to remain alive.” Sleeping adults and temporarily unconscious patients still possess desires in a dispositional sense. Their desires remain part of their developed mental life even when they are not presently conscious.

According to Boonin, however, an early embryo has never possessed any desires because the neurological structures required for conscious mental activity have not developed.

The embryo is biologically alive and human, but Boonin argues that biological humanity alone does not produce a right to life.

Organized Cortical Brain Activity

Boonin proposes organized cortical brain activity as the earliest reasonable marker for acquiring a right to life.

His argument is approximately:

  1. A right to life requires at least the capacity to possess desires.
  2. Desires require organized mental activity.
  3. Organized mental activity depends on functioning structures in the cerebral cortex.
  4. An early fetus lacks organized cortical activity.
  5. Therefore, the early fetus does not yet possess a right to life.

Using the scientific estimates available in his sources, Boonin placed the emergence of this activity roughly between 25 and 32 weeks. He rejected fertilization, implantation, fetal movement, external appearance, viability, and initial brain activity as adequate foundations for the right to life.

His view is not simply that the fetus must feel pain. It is that the brain must have developed sufficiently to support the kinds of desires and conscious interests that he believes ground a right to continued life.

His Response to the Future Like Ours Argument

Don Marquis argues that killing is wrong primarily because it deprives someone of a valuable “future like ours.” Since an unborn child has such a future, abortion is generally wrong.

Boonin agrees that losing a valuable future helps explain the wrongness of killing, but he adds another requirement. The individual must be capable of valuing that future through actual or developing desires.

An early embryo may have a valuable future ahead, but Boonin argues that it cannot yet care about or possess any desire connected to that future. Therefore, he concludes that abortion does not violate the embryo’s right to life.

Abortion Even If the Fetus Is a Person

Boonin’s later book, Beyond Roe, deliberately sets aside the personhood dispute. He asks readers to assume that the fetus is a person with the same basic right to life as anyone else.

He then argues that abortion should remain legal because a right to life does not automatically include a right to use another person’s body.

This develops Judith Jarvis Thomson’s bodily autonomy argument. Boonin’s goal is to show that disagreements about when personhood begins do not have to decide whether abortion should be legal.

McFall v. Shimp

Boonin relies heavily on the real legal case McFall v. Shimp.

Robert McFall had a fatal blood disease and needed a bone marrow transplant. His cousin, David Shimp, was a possible donor but refused. McFall asked a court to compel Shimp to undergo the procedure, but the court refused.

Boonin draws the following principle from the case:

A person’s right to life does not give that person the right to use another person’s body without consent.

McFall’s need was urgent, and Shimp’s refusal contributed to his inability to survive. Yet Shimp could not be legally forced to provide bodily assistance.

Boonin argues that the same principle should apply to pregnancy. Even if the fetus is a person, the government should not force a woman to provide bodily support for the duration of pregnancy.

The Good Samaritan Argument

Boonin describes carrying a pregnancy as a form of Good Samaritan assistance. Continuing the pregnancy may be generous, loving, or morally admirable, but he argues that it cannot always be legally required.

Under this view, abortion may be morally permissible without being the best or most compassionate choice. Boonin distinguishes an action’s permissibility from whether it is admirable, caring, or beyond criticism.

For him, saying that abortion is permissible principally means that it does not violate another person’s enforceable moral right.

Consent and Responsibility

A major objection is that pregnancy following consensual sex differs from forced organ donation. The woman and man voluntarily performed an act that could create a dependent child.

Boonin distinguishes between:

  • Causing someone to become dependent when that person could otherwise have existed independently
  • Causing a new person to exist in a naturally dependent condition

The woman did not take an independently living fetus and make that fetus dependent on her. The fetus could not have existed without beginning life in a dependent condition. Boonin therefore argues that causing the fetus to exist does not necessarily create an obligation to provide bodily support.

He applies this reasoning even when intercourse was voluntary and contraception was not used.

Killing Versus Letting Die

Another objection is that refusing bone marrow allows McFall to die from his disease, while abortion causes the death of a healthy fetus.

Boonin responds by examining whether at least some methods of abortion could be understood as withdrawing support rather than directly killing. If detaching the fetus is morally comparable to disconnecting from the violinist, he argues that the fetus’s death may result from its inability to survive independently.

He also argues that even when abortion is classified as killing rather than letting die, killing is not automatically unjustified in every circumstance involving the unauthorized use of another person’s body.

This remains one of the most disputed parts of his argument.

The Pro-Life Response

The Same Human Being Exists From Fertilization

The embryo who lacks cortical activity is the same living human organism who later develops a functioning cortex, becomes conscious, is born, and matures into an adult.

Organized cortical activity does not create a new individual. It is an ability developed by an individual who already exists.

Pro-life philosophers therefore argue that Boonin confuses the beginning of a human ability with the beginning of the human being who possesses it.

Rights Should Not Depend on Mental Function

Brain activity, consciousness, and desires vary among individuals and across stages of life. If the right to life depends on mental function, human beings with more developed abilities may appear to possess stronger claims than those with fewer abilities.

Boonin attempts to protect sleeping or temporarily unconscious adults by appealing to desires they previously developed. But this makes past mental performance important to present protection.

A newborn, embryo, or person with a profound lifelong cognitive disability cannot appeal to the same history of developed desires. The pro-life concern is that this replaces equal human rights with unequal protection based on mental development.

People Can Be Harmed Without Desiring Otherwise

A person does not need to understand or desire something in order to lose it.

An infant cannot form a mature desire for education, liberty, or a future career, but depriving the infant of those goods can still cause serious harm. Someone can also be wronged without knowing that the wrong occurred.

Pro-life thinkers argue that death harms the unborn child because it deprives that actual individual of life and an entire human future, whether or not the child can presently understand the loss.

Pregnancy Is Not Organ Donation

McFall was an adult stranger dying from a disease. Shimp did not cause him to exist, was not his parent, and did not directly kill him. Refusing bone marrow left McFall to die from his existing illness.

The fetus is the woman’s child, not an unrelated stranger. The child is normally healthy and developing in the only way human beings can survive at that age. Abortion introduces the actions or conditions that cause the child’s death.

The analogy also overlooks parental responsibility. Parents are required to provide forms of care to their children that they do not owe to unrelated adults.

Dependence Is Not a Disease

Boonin argues that the parents cause the fetus to exist but do not cause the fetus’s natural dependency. Pro-life critics answer that creating a dependent child is precisely what generates parental responsibility.

A newborn’s inability to feed, shelter, or protect herself is also natural. Parents did not cause a disease that made the newborn dependent, but they still have duties because they brought a vulnerable child into existence.

Natural dependency does not make a child an intruder or eliminate the obligations of those responsible for the child’s existence.

Abortion Is Not Simply Refusing Assistance

Most abortions do not merely leave the child untouched while declining to provide an additional resource.

Medication abortion alters the conditions maintaining the pregnancy and expels the embryo or fetus. Surgical abortion uses suction or instruments to detach and remove the child, frequently causing bodily destruction in the process.

Pro-life critics therefore argue that abortion is ordinarily an act that causes death, not simply a refusal to rescue someone already dying.

Bodily Autonomy Has Limits

People possess strong rights over their bodies, but bodily autonomy does not include a general right to use one’s body to harm another person.

The abortion debate cannot be resolved merely by establishing that the fetus depends on the woman. It must also ask whether the dependent child has a right not to be intentionally killed and whether parents have special duties toward their children.

Why Boonin Matters

Boonin is important because he offers one of the most comprehensive and intellectually serious defenses of abortion. He does not rely merely on slogans or assume that the fetus is biologically insignificant.

Instead, he addresses both major questions in the debate:

  1. Does the fetus possess a right to life?
  2. Would abortion violate that right even if it exists?

His work shows why answering only the biological question may not persuade every abortion advocate. A complete pro-life response must also explain human equality, parental responsibility, bodily rights, and the difference between refusing extraordinary aid and intentionally ending a child’s life.

Major Works

WorkImportance
A Defense of AbortionDevelops Boonin’s desire-based account of the right to life and his defense of Thomson’s bodily autonomy argument
Beyond Roe: Why Abortion Should Be Legal Even if the Fetus Is a PersonArgues that abortion should remain legal even if the fetus has full personhood
“A Defense of ‘A Defense of Abortion’”Responds to the responsibility objection against Thomson’s violinist argument
What’s Wrong? Applied Ethicists and Their CriticsExamines abortion and other disputed issues in applied ethics
The Palgrave Handbook of Philosophy and Public PolicyCollects philosophical approaches to law and public policy