Who Was Don Marquis?
Donald Bagley “Don” Marquis (1935–2022) was an American philosopher whose work focused primarily on ethics and medical ethics.
Marquis taught philosophy at the University of Kansas from 1967 until his retirement in 2016. He studied anatomy and physiology before earning graduate degrees in history, the history and philosophy of science, and philosophy.
He is best known for his 1989 essay, “Why Abortion Is Immoral,” published in The Journal of Philosophy. The essay has become one of the most widely discussed philosophical arguments against abortion.
The Future Like Ours Argument
Marquis begins by asking why killing an adult human being is normally such a serious moral wrong.
His answer is that killing deprives the victim of an entire valuable future. The victim loses future experiences, relationships, activities, achievements, enjoyments, and choices.
What primarily makes killing wrong is neither its effect on the murderer nor its effect on the victim’s friends and relatives, but its effect on the victim.
Marquis argues that a fetus ordinarily possesses the same general kind of valuable future. Abortion deprives the fetus of that future and is therefore prima facie, or presumptively, seriously wrong.
His argument does not begin with religious doctrine or with the disputed claim that the fetus is already a person. Instead, it asks whether the reason killing adults and children is wrong also applies to the unborn.
Why His Argument Is Significant
Marquis’s approach shifted the abortion debate away from the question:
Is the fetus presently a person?
and toward the question:
What does abortion take away from the individual who is killed?
This allows the argument to apply even when an embryo or fetus is not conscious, self-aware, or capable of desiring continued life.
Marquis also argues that his position does not condemn contraception. Before fertilization, no single existing organism possesses the future of the later child. After fertilization, an identifiable human organism exists and can be deprived of its own future.
A Presumption, Not an Absolute Prohibition
Marquis describes abortion as presumptively wrong rather than wrong under every imaginable circumstance.
His argument leaves open the possibility that abortion could be justified in rare cases involving a loss at least as serious as the child’s lost future. It does not provide a complete analysis of medical emergencies, bodily autonomy, or abortion law.
The Future Like Ours Argument is therefore best understood as an explanation of the harm abortion causes, not as a complete pro-life ethical or legal theory.
Other Work
Marquis also wrote about physician-assisted suicide, death, clinical research, and other questions in bioethics. His broader work examined when death harms an individual and how medical decisions should account for a patient’s interests.
Legacy
Marquis provided one of the strongest secular arguments against abortion in contemporary philosophy.
His argument remains influential because it does not base the wrongness of killing solely on present consciousness, intelligence, self-awareness, religious belief, or species membership. It focuses instead on the life the individual loses.
Supporters view this as a powerful explanation of why abortion seriously harms the unborn child. Critics continue to debate personal identity, fetal interests, bodily autonomy, and whether a future can already be valuable to someone who has never been conscious.