Francis J. Beckwith

Who Is Francis J. Beckwith?

Francis J. Beckwith is an American philosopher, legal scholar, and author. He is Professor of Philosophy and Church-State Studies at Baylor University, where he also teaches in areas including political science, religion, and medical humanities.

Beckwith writes about ethics, law, religion, and public policy. Within the abortion debate, he is best known for Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, a detailed academic defense of the pro-life position.

His Argument Against Abortion

Beckwith’s central argument can be summarized as follows:

  1. From fertilization, the unborn child is a distinct, living human organism.
  2. The unborn child is the same individual who later becomes an infant, adolescent, and adult.
  3. Every human being has intrinsic value simply because of what he or she is.
  4. Differences in size, development, location, and dependency do not determine whether someone possesses basic human rights.
  5. Abortion is generally wrong because it intentionally ends the life of an innocent human being.

Beckwith argues that the central question is not whether the unborn child looks or functions like an adult. The question is whether the unborn child is the same kind of being as an adult. He concludes that the answer is yes.

The Substance View

Beckwith defends the substance view of human persons. Under this view, a human being remains the same individual throughout every stage of life, despite dramatic changes in appearance, ability, and independence.

The embryo does not become a different kind of being when consciousness, viability, or self-awareness develops. These are abilities acquired by an already-existing human being.

Beckwith argues that this view provides a stronger foundation for human equality than theories that base personhood on presently exercisable capacities. If consciousness or intelligence determines basic rights, human worth could increase, decrease, or disappear as those abilities change.

Bodily Autonomy

Beckwith directly addresses the argument that even if an unborn child is a person, the child has no right to use the mother’s body. This argument is commonly illustrated by Judith Jarvis Thomson’s Famous Violinist thought experiment.

Beckwith argues that pregnancy differs from the violinist example in several morally important ways:

  • The unborn child is the woman’s offspring, not an unrelated stranger.
  • Parents generally have special responsibilities toward their dependent children.
  • Pregnancy is the natural means by which human beings care for their children at that stage of life.
  • Most abortions intentionally cause fetal death rather than merely withdrawing extraordinary medical assistance.
  • Except in cases of rape, the child’s dependency ordinarily results from a voluntary act capable of creating a dependent human being.

These points do not mean pregnancy is easy or without serious burdens. Beckwith’s position is that bodily autonomy, although important, does not automatically include a right to intentionally kill another human being.

Popular Arguments

Beckwith also examines commonly heard arguments such as:

  • “No one knows when life begins.”
  • “You cannot impose your morality on others.”
  • “If abortion is illegal, women will seek dangerous abortions.”
  • “The unborn child is only a potential person.”
  • “Abortion is a private choice.”
  • “Pro-life beliefs are merely religious.”

He argues that these claims often avoid the central question of what the unborn child is. If the unborn child is a human being with basic rights, abortion cannot be treated solely as a private medical decision.

Abortion and the Law

Beckwith argues that protecting unborn children does not require government to impose a religious doctrine. Laws against homicide and other forms of violence already reflect the moral principle that innocent human beings should be protected.

He also challenges the idea that government can remain neutral on abortion. Permitting abortion is itself a legal judgment that the unborn child’s life may be intentionally ended. The law must therefore take a position, either recognizing the unborn as members of the human community or withholding that protection.

Major Works

WorkSignificance
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion ChoiceBeckwith’s comprehensive philosophical, legal, and political defense of the pro-life position
Politically Correct DeathAn earlier examination of abortion ethics and arguments for abortion rights
“Personal Bodily Rights, Abortion, and Unplugging the Violinist”Responds to Judith Jarvis Thomson’s bodily-rights defense of abortion
“The Explanatory Power of the Substance View of Persons”Defends the view that human beings retain their identity and moral value throughout development

Influence

Beckwith is important to pro-life thought because he brings scientific, philosophical, legal, and political questions together in one argument. He also responds directly to sophisticated abortion-rights thinkers such as Judith Jarvis Thomson, David Boonin, and Ronald Dworkin.

His work is frequently studied alongside that of Patrick Lee, Robert P. George, Christopher Kaczor, and other philosophers who ground human equality in human nature rather than present ability.