Joseph Boyle

Who Was Germain Grisez?

Germain Grisez was an American Catholic philosopher and moral theologian who lived from 1929 to 2018. He taught at Georgetown University, the University of Virginia, the University of Regina, and Mount St. Mary’s University, where he served as professor of Christian ethics for approximately 30 years.

Grisez is best known as one of the founders of the New Natural Law theory, an influential modern development of the natural law tradition. His ideas were later developed in collaboration with philosophers such as John Finnis and Joseph Boyle.

He wrote extensively about abortion, contraception, euthanasia, marriage, medical ethics, moral responsibility, and the relationship between Christian faith and practical reason.

The New Natural Law Theory

Grisez began developing the New Natural Law theory during the 1960s. He believed that some traditional explanations of natural law made moral reasoning appear to begin with abstract claims about human nature and then deduce specific rules from them.

Grisez instead argued that practical reasoning begins with our direct recognition of certain basic human goods. These goods provide understandable reasons for acting and are valuable for their own sake.

His approach remained strongly influenced by Thomas Aquinas, although it also departed from some traditional interpretations of Aquinas.

Basic Human Goods

Grisez argued that human fulfillment includes several basic goods that cannot be reduced to pleasure, personal preference, money, or social usefulness.

His descriptions developed over time, but the goods include:

  • Life, health, and bodily integrity
  • Knowledge and truth
  • Appreciation of beauty
  • Skilled work and play
  • Friendship and justice
  • Marriage and family
  • Personal integrity and practical reasonableness
  • Religion and harmony with God

These goods are not merely tools for obtaining something else. Health is not valuable only because it helps someone earn money. Friendship is not valuable only because it produces pleasure. Life is not valuable only when a person can perform certain functions.

Each is an aspect of genuine human flourishing.

Human Life as a Basic Good

For Grisez, human life is a basic and intrinsic good. It should be respected in every human being rather than valued according to age, ability, health, usefulness, or personal desire.

This does not mean that biological survival must be preserved at every cost. Medical treatment may sometimes be refused when it is ineffective or excessively burdensome. A person may also accept reasonable risks for the sake of other people or important responsibilities.

However, Grisez distinguishes accepting death from choosing death. It is never morally permissible to make the destruction of innocent human life the object of one’s choice, either as an end or as the means of achieving another goal.

Moral Absolutes

Grisez strongly defended the existence of moral absolutes, meaning that some kinds of actions are always wrong to choose deliberately.

He rejected proportionalism, the idea that a person may intentionally commit an otherwise wrongful act when it appears likely to produce a greater balance of good consequences over bad ones.

Grisez argued that basic human goods cannot be measured on a single scale. Life, knowledge, friendship, and justice do not have a shared numerical value that allows someone to calculate whether destroying one is sufficiently compensated by producing more of another.

This means that an innocent person may not be intentionally killed even to achieve compassionate or socially desirable results.

Grisez’s Argument Against Abortion

Grisez presented an extensive defense of unborn life in his 1970 book, Abortion: The Myths, the Realities, and the Arguments.

His position can be summarized as follows:

  1. A new human individual begins to exist at fertilization.
  2. Human life is a basic good rather than a possession whose value depends on developed abilities.
  3. The unborn child’s life is an instance of that basic human good.
  4. Induced abortion ordinarily involves choosing the child’s death as an end or as the means of ending the pregnancy.
  5. Intentionally attacking an innocent human life is always morally wrong.
  6. Therefore, induced abortion is ordinarily morally impermissible.

Grisez rejected the claim that unborn children may be killed because they are small, dependent, unwanted, disabled, or unable to exercise mental abilities. None of these conditions changes what the child is or removes the basic good of his or her life.

Direct and Indirect Killing

A major part of Grisez’s ethics is the distinction between intending death and foreseeing death as an unintended side effect.

A direct killing is not necessarily defined by physical closeness or by the type of medical procedure used. It is direct when death is included in what the person chooses, either as the goal or as the means of achieving the goal.

An indirect death occurs when someone chooses a morally acceptable action for a serious reason while foreseeing, but not choosing, that death may result.

This distinction is essential in medical situations involving pregnancy. Grisez’s framework allows treatment of a mother’s serious medical condition when the child’s death cannot be prevented, provided that killing the child is not the goal or the means of treatment.

The death remains tragic, but allowing an unavoidable death is morally different from choosing to cause it.

Abortion and Difficult Circumstances

Grisez recognized that pregnancies may involve severe illness, poverty, abandonment, fetal disability, rape, or other profound suffering. He did not argue that these circumstances are unimportant.

His position was that suffering cannot justify intentionally destroying an innocent person. The proper response is to address the hardship while respecting every human life involved.

This places responsibilities not only on the pregnant woman, but also on fathers, families, physicians, churches, governments, and communities. A society that prohibits abortion while abandoning women and children would fail to promote the complete range of human goods Grisez believed morality requires.

Human Equality

Grisez’s philosophy supports human equality by grounding moral protection in the good of each person’s life rather than in intelligence, independence, consciousness, or social recognition.

If dignity depends on developed abilities, people will possess unequal value because abilities always come in degrees. A newborn cannot reason like an adult, and a person with a profound disability may never exercise the same abilities as others.

Under Grisez’s approach, their lives remain genuine instances of the basic human good of life. They may not be treated merely as obstacles to someone else’s goals.

Freedom and Moral Choice

Grisez believed that free choices do more than produce external results. Through our choices, we also shape our character and establish the kind of people we become.

A person who intentionally attacks a basic human good does not merely cause a harmful outcome. That person also directs his or her will against an aspect of human flourishing.

Freedom, therefore, is not simply the ability to obtain whatever one wants. Authentic freedom means choosing in ways that remain open to the good of every person affected.

In the abortion debate, this means that personal autonomy cannot include an unlimited authority to destroy another human life.

Christian Moral Theology

Although Grisez developed philosophical arguments accessible to reason, he was also explicitly Catholic. His multivolume work, The Way of the Lord Jesus, attempted to present Christian morality as a positive calling to participate in Christ’s redemptive work.

He believed moral rules are not arbitrary restrictions imposed by religion. They protect the goods that allow human persons and communities to flourish.

His work defended Catholic teaching on abortion, contraception, euthanasia, marriage, sexuality, and other disputed subjects, while connecting those teachings to a larger vision of Christian life.

Criticism of His Theory

The New Natural Law theory has generated significant debate.

Some traditional Thomists argue that Grisez separates practical reasoning too sharply from metaphysics and from a prior understanding of human nature. Other critics question how the list of basic goods is identified or why those goods should be treated as incapable of being measured against one another.

Consequentialist and proportionalist philosophers also argue that absolute prohibitions can prevent actions that would produce better overall results.

Grisez and his collaborators responded that treating human goods as measurable quantities allows individuals to sacrifice innocent people whenever doing so seems socially useful. Moral absolutes, in their view, protect every person from being intentionally used or destroyed for someone else’s benefit.

Influence on Modern Pro-Life Thought

Grisez helped give contemporary pro-life philosophy a systematic ethical framework. He did more than argue that the unborn child is biologically human. He explained why human life is a basic good, why intentions matter, and why good consequences cannot justify intentionally killing an innocent person.

His work influenced thinkers including:

  • John Finnis
  • Joseph Boyle
  • Robert P. George
  • Patrick Lee
  • Christopher Tollefsen

Through these thinkers, Grisez’s ideas continue to shape philosophical arguments about abortion, euthanasia, assisted suicide, embryo research, marriage, and medical ethics.

Major Works

WorkImportance
Contraception and the Natural LawIntroduced important elements of Grisez’s developing approach to practical reason and moral choice
Abortion: The Myths, the Realities, and the ArgumentsProvides his most extensive treatment of abortion, unborn life, law, and the ethics of killing
“Toward a Consistent Natural-Law Ethics of Killing”Applies his moral theory to abortion and other questions involving intentional killing
The Way of the Lord JesusHis major multivolume work on Christian morality, human goods, responsibility, and practical life
“Practical Principles, Moral Truth, and Ultimate Ends”Coauthored with John Finnis and Joseph Boyle, presenting a systematic account of New Natural Law theory