Who Is Peter Singer?
Peter Singer is an Australian moral philosopher and the DeCamp Professor of Bioethics Emeritus at Princeton University. He is one of the world’s most influential and controversial writers on applied ethics.
Singer is widely known for his work on animal welfare, global poverty, charitable giving, euthanasia, abortion, and infanticide. His major books include Animal Liberation, Practical Ethics, Rethinking Life and Death, and The Life You Can Save.
Utilitarianism
Singer approaches ethical questions through utilitarianism, which generally judges actions by their consequences for everyone affected.
He is particularly associated with preference utilitarianism. Under this view, morality should give equal consideration to comparable interests and preferences, regardless of whose interests they are.
For example, if a human and an animal can both experience pain, the animal’s pain should not be dismissed merely because the animal is not human. Singer calls the unjustified preference for human interests speciesism, comparing it to other forms of prejudice based upon morally irrelevant characteristics.
Human Being Versus Person
Singer distinguishes between a biological human being and a person.
| Term | Meaning in Singer’s philosophy |
|---|---|
| Human being | A biological member of the species Homo sapiens |
| Person | A rational, self-aware being capable of understanding itself as existing through time |
Under this definition, not every human being is a person, and some nonhuman animals may possess person-like characteristics.
Embryos, fetuses, newborns, and some severely cognitively impaired human beings are biologically human but may not qualify as persons under Singer’s psychological standard.
Sentience and Self-Awareness
Singer assigns moral importance to two different levels of mental life.
Sentient Beings
A sentient being can experience pleasure, pain, or suffering. Its experiences matter morally because it has an interest in avoiding pain.
A sentient fetus may therefore have interests that must be considered, even if the fetus is not a person.
Self-Aware Persons
A person understands himself or herself as a continuing individual with a past and future. Persons can form preferences and plans about their continued lives.
Singer argues that killing a person is especially serious because it frustrates that individual’s desire to continue living. A being that has never developed self-awareness cannot form that type of future-directed preference.
His View of Abortion
Singer rejects the argument that every member of the human species has an equal right to life simply because he or she is human.
His reasoning can be summarized as follows:
- Biological humanity alone does not create a strong right to life.
- A strong right to life is connected to personhood, including rationality and self-awareness.
- A fetus is not self-aware and cannot understand itself as existing through time.
- An early fetus is not sentient and therefore has no conscious interests.
- A later fetus may be sentient, so unnecessary pain should be avoided, but it still does not possess the same right to life as a person.
- Abortion may therefore be morally permissible.
Singer’s argument differs from Judith Jarvis Thomson’s bodily-autonomy defense. Thomson temporarily grants that the fetus may be a person. Singer directly denies that a fetus possesses personhood or an equal right to life.
His View of Infanticide
Singer acknowledges that birth does not suddenly produce rationality or self-awareness. A newborn remains unable to understand himself or herself as a continuing subject with future plans.
He therefore argues that killing a newborn is not morally equivalent to killing a self-aware person. In his framework, neither a fetus nor a newborn possesses a person’s strong desire-based right to continued life.
However, Singer does not conclude that anyone may kill any newborn for any reason. He argues that several other interests normally protect infants:
- Parents ordinarily love and want their child.
- Other people may want to adopt and care for an unwanted infant.
- Allowing infants to be killed freely would cause fear and damage important social relationships.
- An infant can experience pain and therefore has an interest in avoiding suffering.
- Decisions affect parents, siblings, medical professionals, and the wider community.
For these reasons, Singer says that killing a healthy newborn with loving parents would be wrong.
Disabled Newborns
Singer’s most controversial position concerns newborns with serious disabilities.
He has argued that when a newborn has a profound disability, parents should sometimes be permitted, together with physicians, to decide that the child should die. Examples he has discussed include anencephaly, trisomy 18, and severe forms of spina bifida.
His argument considers:
- The amount of pain and suffering the child is expected to experience
- The child’s prospects for pleasure and a worthwhile life
- The effects upon the parents and family
- The availability of treatment
- Whether anyone else is willing to care for the child
- Whether ending the child’s life might allow the parents to have another child with better prospects
Singer and philosopher Helga Kuhse developed this position in Should the Baby Live? The Problem of Handicapped Infants.
Singer describes the proposed act as nonvoluntary euthanasia because the newborn is incapable of either requesting or refusing death. He distinguishes it from involuntary euthanasia, in which someone capable of choosing is killed against his or her wishes.
The Replacement Argument
In some versions of his utilitarian reasoning, Singer argues that the death of a newborn may be morally offset if the parents later have another child whose life contains greater overall well-being.
This is sometimes called a replacement argument. It treats the moral question partly in terms of the total amount of happiness, suffering, and fulfilled preferences produced by different possible outcomes.
The argument is especially controversial because it appears to treat individual children as replaceable. Critics argue that each child is a unique human being whose life cannot be balanced against the possible life of a future child.
Singer’s Response to Criticism
Singer says his position is often misrepresented as a general endorsement of killing newborns or disabled people. He emphasizes that:
- He does not support killing self-aware disabled people.
- Many people with disabilities live happy and valuable lives.
- A newborn’s death may be considered only in restricted circumstances.
- Parents and physicians should make informed decisions.
- Pain, suffering, family interests, and the availability of other caregivers must be considered.
- Being a newborn without a disability does not by itself make killing permissible.
Nevertheless, Singer maintains that no newborn is a person in the strict psychological sense. The protections he gives infants therefore arise largely from sentience, relationships, consequences, and the interests of others rather than from an inherent right to life shared equally by all human beings.
The Disability-Rights Critique
Disability advocates have strongly criticized Singer’s views. They argue that judgments about whether a disabled child will have a worthwhile life are often based upon inaccurate assumptions about disability.
Their objections include:
- Physicians and parents may underestimate the quality of life possible with a disability.
- Medical predictions about future suffering and ability can be uncertain.
- Social barriers can cause suffering that is incorrectly attributed to the disability itself.
- Permitting others to judge whether a child’s life is worth living places vulnerable people at risk.
- A child’s right to life should not depend upon whether parents or society consider that child burdensome.
- Treating disabled infants differently can reinforce discrimination against the wider disabled community.
Singer responds that refusing to evaluate quality of life can also prolong severe and unavoidable suffering. Critics answer that compassionate care should relieve suffering without intentionally killing the person experiencing it.
The Pro-Life Critique
Rights Become Unequal
Rationality, self-awareness, and the ability to form preferences exist in degrees. If these capacities determine the strength of the right to life, then human beings do not possess equal fundamental rights.
Infants, people with profound cognitive disabilities, and patients with serious brain injuries may receive weaker protection than highly developed adults.
Newborns Are Excluded
Singer’s willingness to permit some infanticide is not an accidental misunderstanding of his view. It follows from his premise that newborns are not persons.
Pro-life critics argue that this conclusion exposes the danger of separating personhood from biological humanity.
A Human Being Exists Before Self-Awareness
The embryo, fetus, newborn, and self-aware adult are not different organisms. They are developmental stages in the life of the same human individual.
A newborn does not begin to exist when self-awareness develops. Self-awareness is an ability acquired by the human being who already exists.
Death Harms Those Who Cannot Understand It
A human being does not need to understand death or desire continued existence before death can harm him or her.
Killing an infant permanently deprives that child of every future relationship, experience, choice, and opportunity, even though the infant cannot presently imagine those losses.
Consequences Do Not Justify Every Means
Utilitarian reasoning can permit intentionally killing one individual when doing so is expected to produce greater overall well-being.
The pro-life view holds that every innocent human being possesses an inviolable dignity that cannot be outweighed by calculations about burdens, usefulness, disability, or the possible happiness of others.
Singer Versus the Human Equality View
| Singer’s view | Human equality or substance view |
|---|---|
| Moral status depends upon sentience, preferences, and self-awareness | Basic dignity belongs to every human being |
| Not all human beings are persons | Every human being is a person |
| Some animals may have stronger claims than some humans | Human rights are grounded in shared human nature |
| Newborns do not have a person’s right to life | Newborns possess the same basic right to life as adults |
| Some infanticide may be morally permissible | Intentionally killing an innocent newborn is always wrong |
| Outcomes and total well-being may justify killing | An innocent person may not be killed as a means to a better outcome |
Importance in the Abortion Debate
Singer is important because he applies capacity-based personhood and utilitarianism consistently across abortion, animal ethics, disability, euthanasia, and infanticide.
Rather than claiming that birth mysteriously creates full moral worth, he acknowledges that newborns lack the same psychological abilities as fetuses. His conclusions reveal the fundamental choice at the center of the personhood debate: whether human rights belong to every human being or only to individuals who possess particular mental abilities.
Major Works
| Work | Significance |
|---|---|
| Practical Ethics | Presents Singer’s views on personhood, abortion, euthanasia, infanticide, animals, and global poverty |
| Should the Baby Live?, with Helga Kuhse | Argues that parents and physicians may sometimes permit or cause the death of severely disabled newborns |
| Rethinking Life and Death | Criticizes the traditional principle that every human life has equal and inviolable value |
| Animal Liberation | Applies equal consideration of interests to animals and criticizes speciesism |
| The Life You Can Save | Argues that affluent people have strong obligations to help people living in extreme poverty |