Who Is Scott Klusendorf?
Scott Klusendorf is an American pro-life author, speaker, and educator. He is the president of Life Training Institute, an organization that trains students and adults to defend the pro-life position through science and philosophy.
Klusendorf earned his undergraduate degree from UCLA and a master’s degree in Christian apologetics from Biola University. He has taught pro-life apologetics at the graduate level and presented at universities, churches, schools, pregnancy centers, and public debates.
His best-known book is The Case for Life: Equipping Christians to Engage the Culture.
What Is a Pro-Life Apologist?
An apologist is someone who presents a reasoned defense of a belief. In this context, it does not mean apologizing or expressing regret.
Klusendorf’s role differs somewhat from that of academic philosophers such as Patrick Lee, Robert P. George, Francis Beckwith, and Christopher Kaczor. He translates many of their philosophical ideas into short, memorable arguments that ordinary people can understand and use in conversation.
The Central Question
Klusendorf teaches that the abortion debate turns on one fundamental question:
What is the unborn?
Arguments about privacy, choice, poverty, unwanted pregnancy, and personal circumstances cannot settle whether abortion is justified until the identity and moral status of the unborn child are addressed.
If the unborn child is not a human being with a right to life, abortion may require little moral justification. If the unborn child is a human being with equal moral worth, however, arguments used to justify abortion must be strong enough to justify intentionally killing any other human being.
The Pro-Life Syllogism
Klusendorf summarizes the pro-life argument in three steps:
- It is wrong to intentionally kill an innocent human being.
- Abortion intentionally kills an innocent human being.
- Therefore, abortion is wrong.
This is a syllogism, meaning a logical argument in which a conclusion follows from stated premises. Someone wishing to refute it must show that at least one premise is false or that the conclusion does not logically follow.
Klusendorf argues that biological evidence supports the second premise because the embryo is a distinct, living, and whole human organism from fertilization. Philosophy is then needed to determine whether every human being possesses an equal right to life.
The SLED Test
Klusendorf popularized the SLED test, an acronym developed from the work of philosopher Stephen Schwarz. It identifies four differences between unborn and born human beings:
| Difference | Klusendorf’s response |
|---|---|
| Size | Being smaller does not make someone less human or less valuable. |
| Level of development | Less-developed humans, including infants and children, do not possess fewer basic rights. |
| Environment | A person’s location, whether inside or outside the womb, does not determine what that person is. |
| Degree of dependency | Depending upon another person for survival does not eliminate one’s humanity or right to life. |
The SLED test is not intended to prove every part of the pro-life position by itself. It demonstrates that these differences do not adequately explain why an unborn human may be intentionally killed while a born human may not.
“Trot Out the Toddler”
Klusendorf often tests abortion arguments by asking whether the same reasoning would justify killing a toddler.
For example, someone might argue that abortion is justified because raising a child would create financial hardship. Klusendorf responds that financial hardship would not justify killing a two-year-old. The argument therefore assumes that the unborn child lacks the toddler’s moral status.
This method does not claim that pregnancy and parenting are identical experiences. Its purpose is to reveal the unstated assumption behind many abortion arguments: that the unborn are not valuable human beings like born children. The discussion must then return to whether that assumption is correct.
Responding to Bodily Autonomy
Klusendorf argues that bodily autonomy is important but not absolute. People may generally control their bodies, but they may not use their bodies to intentionally harm innocent human beings.
He also challenges comparisons between pregnancy and being involuntarily connected to a stranger, as in Judith Jarvis Thomson’s Famous Violinist argument. An unborn child is the mother’s offspring rather than a stranger, and parents ordinarily have special obligations toward their dependent children.
Klusendorf further distinguishes abortion from simply refusing bodily assistance. Abortion procedures generally cause or intentionally bring about the child’s death rather than merely allowing the child to die from an independent illness.
Hard Cases
Klusendorf distinguishes between emotional hardship and the underlying moral question. Pregnancies resulting from rape, severe fetal diagnoses, poverty, or abandonment involve real suffering and should be met with compassion and practical assistance. However, he argues that these circumstances do not change the identity of the unborn child.
In life-threatening pregnancies, he distinguishes between intentionally killing the child and performing necessary treatment intended to save the mother when the child’s death cannot be prevented. This distinction rests on the difference between an intended death and a foreseen but unintended death.
How He Teaches Pro-Life Advocacy
Klusendorf encourages advocates to:
- State the central argument clearly.
- Use scientific evidence to establish what the unborn child is.
- Use philosophy to explain why developmental differences do not determine human value.
- Ask questions rather than delivering lengthy speeches.
- Avoid changing the subject to unrelated political disputes.
- Treat opponents respectfully while remaining clear about what abortion does.
- Distinguish arguments from the motives or personal character of the person presenting them.
His approach is designed to make the pro-life case understandable without requiring specialized training in philosophy or medicine.
Major Works and Contributions
| Work | Significance |
|---|---|
| The Case for Life | Klusendorf’s principal guide to defending the pro-life position through science, philosophy, and practical conversation |
| Pro-Life 101 | A concise introduction to presenting and defending the pro-life argument |
| Life Training Institute | Trains students, educators, churches, and advocates in pro-life reasoning and communication |
| The Case for Life course and podcast | Applies pro-life arguments to current objections, ethical questions, and public debates |
Influence
Klusendorf is one of the most influential popularizers of philosophical pro-life apologetics. His central question, formal syllogism, SLED test, and “trot out the toddler” method have become widely used by pro-life speakers and organizations.
His primary contribution is not the creation of a new theory of personhood. It is making sophisticated arguments about human equality accessible, memorable, and usable in ordinary conversations.