Understanding the Argument
Learning that an unborn child may have a severe disability or life-limiting condition can be devastating. The child may face significant suffering, require extensive medical treatment, or die before or shortly after birth. Continuing the pregnancy may also expose the parents to months of grief, uncertainty, and difficult medical decisions.
According to this argument, abortion allows parents to prevent suffering and avoid prolonging an inevitable tragedy. The decision should therefore remain between the parents and their doctors, particularly when the child has little chance of surviving.
“Severe” Is Used Broadly
“Severe fetal diagnosis” is not one clear medical category. It may refer to:
- A disability compatible with a long life
- A condition requiring medical treatment, either relatively minor to significant
- A diagnosis associated with shortened life expectancy
- An uncertain prognosis
- A condition expected to cause death before or shortly after birth
Those situations are not all the same. A broad exception for “severe” diagnoses can permit abortion based on disability, predicted quality of life, or a physician’s subjective judgment about which lives are worth continuing.
One example: Many would not consider a cleft palate as a severe diagnoses worthy of ending the pregnancy considering the very high success rate of surgical treatment; however, there are abortions obtained every year against unborn children due to a cleft palate diagnosis.
Prenatal Diagnoses Are Often Wrong
Prenatal screening estimates the likelihood of certain conditions. It does not provide a definitive diagnosis. ACOG acknowledges that cell-free DNA screening can produce false-positive and false-negative results and recommends diagnostic testing after a positive screen.
Even when diagnostic testing confirms a condition, doctors may not be able to predict precisely how severely it will affect that particular child. ACOG’s guidance on perinatal palliative care acknowledges that prenatal predictions are not infallible and that postnatal diagnoses or outcomes can differ from what doctors anticipated.
This does not mean families should ignore medical evidence but it does mean that prenatal diagnoses should not be used to make irreversible decisions like killing one’s unborn child.
A Diagnosis Does Not Make a Child Disposable
Even if a child does indeed have a severe condition, they do not lose the right to live because his or her life may be short, medically complicated, or different from what the parents expected.
We would not intentionally kill a newborn because doctors predicted severe disability or only a few weeks of life. We would treat the child, keep the child comfortable, and allow the parents to love and accompany him or her for however long life lasted.
Life does not begin at birth. If killing the newborn would be cruel, performing the same act a few weeks earlier changes nothing.
A diagnosis describes the child’s condition. It does not determine the child’s worth.
Abortion Does Not Treat The Underlying Issue
Abortion does not cure the child’s condition or relieve the child of a disability. It ends the child’s life.
Depending on gestational age and method, abortion involves intentionally causing fetal death via starvation, dismemberment and/or suction aspiration. The procedure eliminates the patient rather than treating the illness.
Calling abortion “compassionate” for the disabled is grossly manipulative. Compassion responds to suffering with care, pain relief, presence, and support. It does not require intentionally killing the person who may suffer.
Perinatal Palliative Care Offers Another Path
Parents do not have to choose between aggressive treatment at all costs and abortion.
Perinatal palliative care supports families who continue pregnancies involving life-limiting diagnoses. A coordinated team can help parents:
- Understand the diagnosis and its uncertainties
- Develop a birth and treatment plan
- Provide comfort and pain management
- Decide which medical interventions would benefit the child
- Spend time with and care for the child
- Receive emotional, spiritual, and bereavement support
ACOG recognizes perinatal palliative comfort care as an established option for life-limiting fetal conditions. This approach allows the child to be cared for without requiring futile treatment and without intentionally causing death.
Having a Disability Does Not Remove Protection Or Dignity
Permitting abortion because of disability creates a troubling double standard.
Society rightly rejects the idea that people with disabilities have less valuable lives after birth. Yet disability-selective abortion applies precisely that judgment before birth: the child may be killed because of a condition that would never justify killing that same child after delivery.
The National Council on Disability has warned that prenatal technologies can reinforce stereotypes, fear, and bias toward people with disabilities. Parents also may receive outdated or unbalanced information that emphasizes hardship without accurately presenting the experiences of people living with the condition.
A humane society should surround families with truthful information and practical support, not suggest that eliminating the child is the solution to disability.
A Short Life Still Has Value
Some children will die despite every effort to save them. That loss is tragic, but the length of a life does not determine whether that life matters.
Parents who continue such pregnancies are choosing to accompany their child through his or her entire natural life, even if that life lasts only minutes or hours after birth.
Death from a medical condition and intentional death through abortion are entirely different moralities. In one, doctors care for a dying child. In the other, the “treatment” is to ensure the child’s death.
The Compassionate Response Is Care
Parents receiving a severe fetal diagnosis deserve time, specialist consultations, diagnostic confirmation, accurate information, and freedom from pressure to abort. They also deserve access to perinatal hospice, medical care, counseling, financial assistance, and bereavement support.
The child deserves care as well. A severe diagnosis does not determine whether the child qualifies as a human being worthy of protection.