Abortion bans are racist.

Understanding the Argument

Critics argue that abortion bans are racist because black women are more likely to obtain abortions and more likely to live in states with restrictive abortion laws.

They also point to racial disparities in maternal health, poverty, and medical treatment. Because these inequalities can make pregnancy and parenthood more difficult, abortion restrictions may place greater burdens on black women.

These concerns deserve attention, but a disproportionate effect does not by itself prove that protecting unborn children is racist.

The Abortion Disparity is Real

According to the CDC’s 2022 data from 32 reporting areas:

  • Black women accounted for 39.5 percent of reported abortions.
  • The abortion rate among black women was 24.4 abortions per 1,000 women.
  • The rate among white women was 5.7 per 1,000.
  • Black women therefore had an abortion rate 4.3 times that of white women.
  • There were 429 abortions for every 1,000 live births among black women, compared with 106 among white women.

These figures do not include every state, and different studies produce somewhat different percentages. Nevertheless, the underlying disparity is clear: abortion ends the lives of black unborn children at a disproportionately high rate.

A Disparate Effect Does Not Settle the Moral Question

A law can deserve scrutiny if it burdens one racial group more heavily. But unequal effects do not automatically establish racist intent or make the prohibited act morally acceptable.

Laws against homicide may affect communities with different homicide rates differently. Laws protecting workers may affect industries differently. The moral question remains whether the law protects a legitimate right and applies that protection equally.

Pro-life laws do not prohibit abortion because the mother is black. They prohibit abortion because the unborn child is a human being with a right not to be intentionally killed. The same protection applies regardless of the race of the mother or child.

The central question is therefore not simply which women obtain the most abortions. It is whether abortion itself violates the rights of another human being.

It Diminishes the Worth of Black Children

The “abortion bans are racist” argument considers the effect of abortion restrictions on the black mothers but excludes the black children whose lives abortion ends.

From the pro-life perspective, that omission is removes half the people affected by abortion from the conversation. If the unborn are human beings, then the higher black abortion rate means that abortion restrictions have the potential to protect a disproportionately high number of black children.

This does not mean the mother’s needs are unimportant, but it does mean racial justice cannot be defined by protecting only one of the two human beings involved.

By this pro-choice logic, the pro-life position could easily argue that abortion freedoms themselves are racist because they kill so many black children.

By this pro-choice logic, the pro-life position could easily argue that abortion freedoms themselves are racist because they kill so many black children.

It Automatically Supports Abortion for All Nine Months

If restricting abortion is racist simply because black women obtain abortions at higher rates, then the argument cannot logically stop after the first trimester.

A ban at 15 weeks would reduce abortion access for some black women. So would a ban at viability. So would a prohibition during the final weeks of pregnancy.

Under that reasoning, every gestational limit would be racist, including a ban immediately before birth.

Therefore, if one believes abortion bans are racist because they prevent black women from receiving abortions – then opposing abortion the day before a due date would be racist too.

Therefore, if one believes abortion bans are racist because they prevent black women from receiving abortions – then opposing abortion the day before a due date would be racist too.

The Eugenic History

The early birth-control movement also has a history connected to eugenics.

Margaret Sanger, whose organizations helped develop into Planned Parenthood, openly aligned herself with eugenic ideas. Eugenics sought to improve society by encouraging reproduction among those considered “fit” and discouraging or preventing it among those labeled “unfit.”

Planned Parenthood now acknowledges that Sanger believed in eugenics, describes the ideology as racist and ableist, and recognizes that she associated with organizations promoting white supremacy. Its New York affiliate removed her name from a health center because of that history.

Admittedly, Sanger primarily advocated contraception rather than abortion. But her record demonstrates that much of reproductive policy has historically been influenced by judgments about who should reproduce. It should therefore concern us when abortion is presented as the expected solution to poverty, disability, or racial inequality.

Therefore, one could point out the irony of accusing abortion bans as being racist when, in fact, this is the history of the founder of the leading provider of abortions.

“Like the advocates of Birth Control, the eugenicists… are seeking to assist the race toward the elimination of the unfit.”

Margaret Sanger, “Birth Control and Racial Betterment,” Birth Control Review, February 1919.

Empower Mothers Rather Than Eliminate Children

Black women also face serious disparities in maternal health. In 2022, the maternal mortality rate for black women was 49.5 deaths per 100,000 live births, compared with 19.0 for white women.

A credible pro-life response takes those dangers seriously. Protecting unborn children should be accompanied by efforts to provide:

  • High-quality prenatal and maternal care
  • Doctors who listen to black patients and respond promptly to complications
  • Safe housing and protection from abuse
  • Workplace and educational accommodations
  • Material and financial assistance
  • Support from fathers
  • Adoption resources when parenting is not possible
  • Continuing care after birth

Many women who obtain abortions face economic pressure. Guttmacher’s 2021–2022 survey found that 41 percent of abortion patients lived below the federal poverty line, while another 30 percent had incomes less than twice that level.

The pro-life answer is not to pretend those hardships don’t exist. Rather, it is to reject the assumption that women must choose between their futures and their children.

Women of every race are strong and capable of doing difficult things. That affirmation must be joined with concrete assistance so that “choose life” is supported by families, communities, institutions, and public policy.

Oftentimes, this rebuttal is countered with false notions that “pro-lifers are only pro-birth”, claiming the movement doesn’t do much to help mothers and children. Click the related piece to learn why that claim is untrue.

The Pro-Life Response

Racial disparities in abortion and maternal health are real. They should motivate better health care, stronger families, economic opportunity, responsible fatherhood, and greater support for mothers and children.

They do not establish that intentionally ending an unborn child’s life is racial justice.

If the unborn child is a human being, then abortion does not solve racial inequality. It eliminates one of the people affected by it.

The pro-life position is that no woman should be abandoned because of her race, income, or pregnancy, and no child should lose the right to life for those reasons either.