Understanding the Argument
Only women become pregnant, so abortion restrictions impose burdens on women that men will never experience. Because these laws limit women’s choices and bodily autonomy, they are inherently discriminatory and prevent women from participating equally in society.
Opposition to Abortion is Not An Opposition to Women
Abortion restrictions affect women directly because pregnancy occurs in the female body. That unequal physical burden is real and should not be minimized.
But a law is not necessarily sexist simply because it applies primarily to one sex. Laws against female genital mutilation, protections for pregnant employees, and maternity-care requirements are sex-specific without being based on hostility toward women.
The relevant question is why abortion is restricted. If the purpose is to control women because they are women, the law would be sexist. If the purpose is to protect unborn human beings from being intentionally killed, the moral basis is the protection of human life.
Contrary to pro-abortion beliefs, pro-lifers would oppose abortion even if men could become pregnant. The objection is to what abortion does to the child, not to the sex of the person seeking it.
Contrary to pro-abortion beliefs, pro-lifers would oppose abortion even if men could become pregnant. The objection is to what abortion does to the child, not to the sex of the person seeking it.
Abortion Involves a Second Human Being
Calling abortion restrictions sexist assumes that abortion concerns only a woman and her body.
But the unborn child is a distinct human organism developing inside the mother. The child has a sex, a body, genetic identity, and life of his or her own.
If unborn children are human beings with moral value, protecting them is not discrimination against women. Society routinely limits choices when those choices would seriously harm another person.
The argument therefore cannot be settled merely by observing that only women experience pregnancy.
Abortion Restrictions Can Save Millions of Girl’s Lives
Abortion restrictions also save female lives. Roughly half of the unborn children protected by these laws are girls. Calling such protections inherently anti-female ignores the female human beings whose lives abortion would otherwise end. This is especially clear in sex-selective abortions, in which unborn girls can be targeted specifically because they are female.
Women Do Not Need Abortion to Be Equal to Men
The claim that women require abortion to participate equally in society can carry a troubling assumption: that women’s natural ability to bear children is an obstacle that must be medically eliminated for them to compete with men.
Women deserve education, employment, safety, healthcare, and economic opportunity without being told that their children must be sacrificed to obtain them.
True equality should make room for pregnancy and motherhood. That includes reasonable workplace accommodations, affordable healthcare, parental leave, flexible education, childcare assistance, and protection from pregnancy discrimination.
A society that presents abortion as the primary solution to women’s difficulties may be accommodating institutions more than women.
Gender equality and female empowerment cannot come at the cost of our children’s lives.
Men Should Be Held Responsible Too
Pregnancy may occur within a woman’s body, but no woman becomes pregnant by herself. Men share responsibility for the children they help conceive.
A consistent pro-life position does not place every burden on women while allowing fathers to disappear. Men should be expected to provide emotional, practical, and financial support to both mother and child. Laws and social institutions should hold fathers accountable rather than treating pregnancy as solely a woman’s problem.
Men cannot share the physical burden equally, but they can and should share the responsibility.
Women Also Oppose Abortion
Women are not united in support of abortion. Many of the people leading pregnancy resource centers, supporting mothers, adopting children, and advocating against abortion are women.
Disagreeing with these women is one thing. Suggesting that their position is inherently anti-woman dismisses their moral reasoning and treats abortion supporters as the only legitimate representatives of women.
Women are capable of evaluating both the hardships of pregnancy and the humanity of unborn children.
Abortion Can Also Be Used Against Women
Legal abortion does not guarantee that every abortion is freely chosen. Women may face pressure from boyfriends, husbands, parents, employers, traffickers, or abusers who view the pregnancy as inconvenient.
Abortion can also be used for sex selection, most often against unborn girls in cultures that prefer sons. Abortion access is not synonymous with respect for women.
Where Else Would This Logic Fail?
We do not normally decide whether a law is just solely by asking whether it affects one sex more than the other.
- Child-support laws often limit a father’s desire to walk away from an unwanted responsibility, but that does not make them sexist against men. The child’s rights take priority over the parent’s preferences.
- Pregnancy-discrimination laws protect women rather than men, but that does not make them anti-male.
- Requirements for prostate-cancer coverage primarily benefit men, but that does not make them sexist.
- Laws against buying sex primarily restrict male behavior, but that does not make them sexist against men. Their purpose is to prevent exploitation.
A restriction is not automatically sexist because it affects one sex more frequently.
Child-support laws often limit a father’s desire to walk away from an unwanted responsibility, but that does not make them sexist against men. The child’s rights take priority over the parent’s preferences.
The Pro-Life Response
Sexism treats women as inferior or denies their equal dignity because they are women. Protecting unborn children does neither.
A just society should not force women to choose between their futures and their children. It should recognize the dignity of women, demand responsibility from men, provide meaningful support to families, and protect unborn girls and boys from intentional killing.
Abortion bans are not sexist because they do not prohibit something harmless merely to control women. They prohibit an act that ends the life of another human being.