The Famous Violinist

Understanding the Argument

Judith Jarvis Thomson’s Famous Violinist analogy asks readers to imagine being kidnapped and involuntarily connected to a sick violinist who needs the use of their kidneys for nine months. Although disconnecting would cause his death, Thomson argues that the reader may do so because the violinist’s right to life does not include a right to use someone else’s body. Applied to pregnancy, the argument maintains that even if the unborn child is a person, a woman may withdraw the use of her body through abortion.

The violinist is a stranger; the unborn child is the woman’s child

The analogy treats pregnancy as a conflict between two unrelated adults. An unborn child, however, is the woman’s biological offspring. Parents ordinarily have special responsibilities toward their dependent children that they do not have toward strangers. The relevant question is therefore not simply whether one person must sustain another, but what parents owe the children who naturally depend upon them.

Pregnancy is not the same as kidnapping

The reader is violently forced into an artificial medical arrangement and bears no responsibility for the violinist’s condition. 99% of pregnancies arise from a voluntary act understood to be capable of creating a dependent child, even when conception was not desired. This makes the relationship morally different from kidnapping.

The analogy more closely resembles pregnancy resulting from rape. Even then, however, the injustice committed against the mother does not establish that an innocent third party may be intentionally killed.

Gestation is not an extraordinary organ donation

The violinist requires access to a stranger’s kidneys because his own body is failing. The unborn child is healthy for his or her developmental stage and depends upon the uterus in the same way every human being naturally does before birth. Pregnancy is not biologically equivalent to being surgically attached to a sick stranger.

Abortion is not merely “unplugging”

Disconnecting the violinist allows him to die from an illness that already threatens his life. Abortion causes the death of a developing human who was not otherwise dying. Depending on the procedure, the child is killed before removal or dies because the procedure deliberately ends the conditions necessary for continued life. This creates an important distinction between withdrawing extraordinary medical treatment and intentionally ending innocent human life.

Bodily autonomy is important but not absolute

People possess strong rights over their bodies, but those rights have limits when their actions seriously harm others. Laws may require parents to provide food, shelter, protection, and other forms of care for their children, even at significant personal cost. Bodily autonomy therefore cannot settle the abortion question until it is first determined whether abortion unjustly harms another human being.

The analogy assumes the very point in dispute

The scenario encourages readers to view the unborn child as an intruder using someone else’s body without permission. But pregnancy creates a unique parent-child relationship, not an invasion by an aggressor. Describing the child as an unwanted bodily user may make abortion seem justified before the moral obligations created by that relationship have been considered.

The Famous Violinist does not establish that parents may intentionally end the lives of their dependent children, or that ordinary pregnancy is morally equivalent to forced medical attachment to a stranger.