Understanding the Argument
The word baby ordinarily refers to a child who has already been born, particularly an infant or newborn. Calling an embryo or fetus a baby, the argument says, is emotionally charged and medically inaccurate.
The correct terms are embryo during early development and fetus later in pregnancy. Therefore, some argue that referring to the unborn as a baby substitutes emotional language for scientific precision.
The Objection to “Baby” Is Understandable
There is a reasonable distinction to make. Baby is not a precise embryological term. Words such as embryo, fetus, newborn, and adolescent identify particular periods of human development.
For that reason, Pro-Life Answers generally does not rely on the word baby when describing the unborn. It instead uses terms such as embryo, fetus, unborn human being, and unborn child.
The pro-life case does not depend on whether someone accepts the word baby.
The Term “Child” is Indisputable
The word child has more than one meaning.
It can describe a developmental period, usually the years between infancy and adulthood. In that sense, an embryo or fetus has not yet reached the childhood stage.
But child also means the offspring, son, or daughter of a parent. In that relational sense, age is irrelevant. A 70-year-old woman can still refer to her 40-year-old son as “my child.” He did not stop being her child when he became an adult.
Modern dictionaries likewise define child not only as a young person, but also as a son, daughter, or human offspring of any age.
The same relationship exists before birth. An embryo or fetus is the biological offspring of a mother and father. Therefore, the unborn is their child, even while also being accurately described as an embryo or fetus.
Embryo and fetus describe the child’s stage of development. Child describes the child’s relationship to the parents.
‘Child’ means the offspring – son or daughter – of a parent. In that relational sense, the developmental stage is irrelevant. A 70-year-old woman can still refer to her 40-year-old son as “my child.”
“Baby” Is Still Appropriate Ordinary Language
Although baby is not the most technical term, that does not make it inaccurate in ordinary conversation. Parents have always used the word affectionately and relationally for their children before and after birth.
Medical organizations do the same. Government and medical pregnancy resources regularly move between embryo, fetus, and baby depending on whether they are describing anatomy or speaking directly to parents.
These terms answer different questions:
- Embryo and fetus describe developmental stage.
- Baby is an ordinary term for a very young child.
- Child describes both a stage of life and a relationship to parents.
Calling the unborn a baby does not deny that the child is scientifically an embryo or fetus. A parent can accurately say, “That is my baby,” while a physician accurately records that the child is a fetus.
The Objection is Selective
Objections to the word baby arise most forcefully when abortion is being discussed.
During a wanted pregnancy, people across the ideological spectrum comfortably ask:
- “When is the baby due?”
- “Is the baby a boy or a girl?”
- “Have you felt the baby move?”
- “What are you naming the baby?”
No one would correct a pregnant friend who refers to her unborn child as her baby by saying, “It is only a fetus.” Such a correction would feel not merely technical, but cruel, because everyone understands what she means.
The terminology often changes when the pregnancy is unwanted or abortion is being defended. The same developing human who is warmly called a baby in one conversation may be reduced to “the fetus” in another.
A wantedness-dependent vocabulary does not change what the unborn is. Whether the parents are excited, frightened, undecided, or seeking an abortion, the same kind of living human being is developing.
No one would correct a pregnant friend who refers to her unborn child as her baby by saying, “It is only a fetus.”
Premature Birth Exposes the Problem
Consider a child born extremely prematurely. Once outside the womb, everyone calls that child a baby, even though a more developed child still inside the womb may continue to be described as “only a fetus.”
A child born at 24 weeks is called a baby. A child at 39 weeks who will be delivered tomorrow may be denied that same word.
If baby identified a strict level of maturity, this would make little sense. The 39-week unborn child is much more developed than the 24-week premature infant. The difference is not age, size, humanity, or degree of development. The difference is whether birth has occurred which then begs the question: “Why is it only birth that determines one’s human value and worth?”
Consider a child born extremely prematurely. Once outside the womb, everyone calls that child a baby, even though a more developed child still inside the womb may continue to be described as “only a fetus.” A child born at 24 weeks is called a baby. A child at 39 weeks who will be delivered tomorrow may be denied that same word.
What Changes At Birth?
Birth is a significant biological transition. The child begins breathing through the lungs, fetal circulation changes, and the child no longer receives oxygen and nutrients through the placenta.
However, birth does not create a new organism. It does not change the child’s species, biological parents, genetic identity, or basic nature.
Consider the child one minute before birth and one minute afterward. The child has moved from inside the uterus to outside it. But nothing occurs during that minute that transforms a nonhuman entity into a human being or someone else’s tissue into a separate child.
The individual after birth is the same individual who existed immediately before birth.
If someone believes the unborn is not a baby until birth, that may describe a preferred use of the word. It does not explain why crossing the birth canal suddenly creates human value or moral worth.
Nothing occurs during birth that transforms a nonhuman entity into a human being or someone else’s tissue into a separate child.
“Embryo” And “Fetus” Are Still Human Beings
Even if one prefers to avoid the term baby, this doesn’t disprove the fact that the unborn child is still a distinct, living human being. An embryo is the developing human during an early stage of life. After eight completed weeks following fertilization, the developing human is called a fetus.
These terms tell us how developed the unborn human is, but they do not tell us that the unborn is something other than human or unrelated to the mother and father.
Calling someone an adolescent does not mean that person is not a child. Calling someone a newborn does not mean that person is not a son or daughter. Likewise, calling the unborn an embryo or fetus does not mean that he or she is not the parents’ child.
Even if one prefers to avoid the term ‘baby’, this doesn’t disprove the fact that the unborn child is still a distinct, living human being.
The Pro-Life Position Does Not Rely on the Word “Baby”
People may reasonably prefer more technical terminology when discussing prenatal development. Someone can avoid the word baby entirely without weakening the pro-life argument.
The relevant facts remain unchanged: the embryo or fetus is a living human organism and the biological offspring of the mother and father. In that clear and ordinary relational sense, the unborn is their child.
Rejecting the word baby does not make the unborn less human, less alive, or less connected to the parents. It changes the terminology, not the reality.
The relevant facts remain unchanged: the embryo or fetus is a living human organism and the biological offspring of the mother and father. In that clear and ordinary relational sense, the unborn is their child.