Understanding the Argument
Pro-lifers often suggest adoption when a woman does not believe she can raise her child. But unless those same pro-lifers have personally adopted children, they have no right to recommend adoption or oppose abortion on that basis.
You Do Not Have to Adopt a Child to Defend That Child
Imagine telling someone:
“Unless you have fostered or adopted an abused child, you have no right to speak out against child abuse.”
The demand would be absurd. Child abuse is wrong regardless of whether every person opposing it is able to bring an abused child into the home.
The same principle applies to abortion. If an unborn child is a human being, that child’s right not to be killed does not depend on whether the person defending that right is prepared to become the child’s parent.
We do not require people to adopt victims before allowing them to oppose their victimization. Protecting someone from being killed and assuming lifelong parental responsibility for that person are entirely different obligations.
It’s like suggesting: Unless you have fostered or adopted an abused child, you have no right to speak out against child abuse.
Adoption Is Not The Price of Opposing Abortion
The pro-life argument is that unborn children are human beings who should not be intentionally killed.
Recognizing someone’s right to live does not make a person responsible for adopting that individual. We do not require advocates to assume lifelong custody of every person protected by the laws they support.
You do not have to become someone’s parent before you may oppose that person being killed.
The responsibility to protect human life is shared broadly. The responsibility to adopt a particular child is personal and requires the right circumstances, preparation, and commitment.
The idea that one must become another’s parent in order to oppose that person being killed is obviously silly.
Not Everyone Should Adopt
Adoption or fostering should never be undertaken to prove a political point or silence an accusation.
Prospective adoptive parents must be able to provide a safe, stable, and permanent home. Some people may be unable to adopt because of:
- Financial limitations
- Health concerns
- Age or family circumstances
- Housing restrictions
- Marital instability
- The needs of children already in the home
- Ineligibility under adoption requirements
- Lack of preparation for adoption-related trauma and loss
A person can support adoption while honestly recognizing that becoming an adoptive parent would not currently serve a child well.
Children need prepared parents, not adults adopting from guilt.
Where Else Would This Logic Fail?
We do not normally require someone to provide the entire solution personally before permitting that person to oppose an injustice.
- You can oppose child abuse without becoming a foster parent.
- You can oppose elder abuse without bringing an elderly stranger into your home.
- You can support organ donation without being medically eligible to donate an organ.
- You can oppose homelessness without personally housing every homeless person.
- You can oppose animal cruelty without adopting every abandoned animal.
- You can support refugee protection without being able to sponsor a refugee family.
Personal involvement is admirable, but it is not a prerequisite for recognizing that another person deserves protection.
Adoption Must Be Suggested Responsibly
Adoption should not be presented as an easy answer or used to dismiss the difficulties of pregnancy.
It is an alternative to parenting, not an alternative to pregnancy. A woman considering adoption still experiences pregnancy, childbirth, separation, and grief.
Someone suggesting adoption should therefore do more than say, “Just give the baby up.” A responsible response includes:
- Listening to what the mother actually wants
- Helping her obtain accurate information
- Supporting her if she wants to parent
- Protecting her from coercion
- Connecting her with ethical adoption professionals
- Respecting her freedom to choose an adoptive family
- Ensuring she receives counseling and continuing support
Would The Standard Hold Up Both Ways?
If only adoptive parents may recommend adoption, then people who have never placed a child for adoption should not be allowed to criticize it. People who have never experienced abortion could likewise be excluded from supporting it.
That standard would reduce moral views to only personal experience, which is not at all practical or realistic. It would not help determine whether abortion is right or whether adoption can serve a child’s best interests.
By this logic, people who have never experienced abortion should likewise be excluded from supporting it.
The Pro-Life Response
Adoption does not make pregnancy easy, and it does not remove every hardship facing a mother. It does, however, offer a way for a child to live when the parents cannot provide continuing care.
A person need not adopt before recognizing or explaining that option. Nor must someone adopt every vulnerable child before opposing abortion.
Pro-lifers should be willing to help in some way, and some will be called to adopt. But adoption should be pursued because it serves a child, not because someone must earn the right to say that killing the child is wrong.