Human Equality and The Substance View

The human-equality argument holds that basic human rights belong equally to every human being. A person’s value does not increase or decrease with age, size, intelligence, health, independence, consciousness, or physical ability.

The related substance view explains why this equality includes embryo and fetuses. It holds that a human being is one enduring entity, or “substance,” who develops through every stage of life. The embryo, fetus, infant, adolescent, and adult are not different kinds of beings. They are different developmental stages of the same individual.

Here, substance does not mean a chemical substance. It means an individual being that remains itself while its appearance, abilities, and level of development change.

The Basic Argument

The argument can be summarized this way:

  1. Every human being possesses equal basic worth and a right not to be intentionally killed.
  2. A new human organism begins to exist at fertilization.
  3. That organism remains the same individual throughout embryonic, fetal, infant, and adult development.
  4. Therefore, the unborn human being possesses the same basic right to life as other human beings.

The argument does not claim that an embryo can think, feel, reason, or survive independently. It claims that human rights should not depend on currently being able to perform those functions. Those who do believe human rights only begin with the ability to perform certain functions follow an exercisable capacity philosophy.

Being Human and Functioning Like an Adult

Supporters distinguish between what someone is and what someone can presently do.

An embryo cannot reason, but neither can a newborn exercise rational thought at an adult level. A sleeping person, someone under anesthesia, and a patient temporarily unconscious are not presently exercising self-awareness or reasoning. Their basic value does not disappear while those abilities are absent.

The substance view argues that humans are rational beings by nature, even when they cannot presently exercise rational abilities. The capacity develops from within the living human organism as that individual matures.

The substance view argues that humans are rational and worthy beings by nature, even when they cannot presently exercise rational abilities.

An embryo does not become a different kind of being when consciousness develops. The same individual who was once an embryo eventually becomes capable of thought, relationships, moral choices, and self-awareness.

Why Equal Rights Cannot Rest on Performance

If basic human worth depends on intelligence, independence, self-awareness, or another developed ability, then human rights will be granted in unequal degrees as humans possess these capacities in unequal degrees.

Adults generally have greater reasoning abilities than infants. Some people are more intelligent, independent, or self-aware than others. People can also lose these abilities through illness, injury, sleep, anesthesia, or disability.

The human-equality view does not deny that abilities matter for some purposes. An infant cannot vote, drive, or make medical decisions. It instead distinguishes these activity-dependent rights from fundamental human rights.

A right to vote may depend on age and competence. The basic right not to be intentionally killed does not.

The Embryo’s Continuity

From fertilization, the embryo is a living organism of the human species with an internal capacity to direct his or her own development. The embryo does not merely contain human cells, as skin tissue does. The embryo is an integrated organism developing as a whole.

The embryo grows by taking in nutrition and directing coordinated development. Although dependent on the mother for protection, oxygen, and nourishment, dependency does not make the embryo part of the mother’s body. Mother and child are biologically connected but remain distinct organisms.

Although dependent on the mother for protection, oxygen, and nourishment, dependency does not make the embryo part of the mother’s body. Mother and child are biologically connected but remain distinct organisms.

The substance view maintains that no later event creates a new individual:

  • Implantation changes the child’s location and relationship to the uterus.
  • A heartbeat marks an important function but does not create the organism.
  • Brain development enables new activities but does not create a new being.
  • Viability changes whether the child might survive outside the uterus.
  • Birth changes environment, dependence, and legal status.

These events affect how the same human being lives and functions. They do not transform a nonhuman entity into a human being.

Major Thinkers

ThinkerContribution
Patrick LeeA philosopher known for defending the view that the unborn child is a complete human organism whose basic moral worth does not depend on developed mental abilities.
Robert P. GeorgeA natural-law scholar who has written with Patrick Lee about human identity, embodied personhood, and why embryos should be treated as human beings rather than disposable biological material.
Francis J. BeckwithDeveloped an accessible moral and legal defense of the substance view in Defending Life, arguing that unborn humans possess the same intrinsic nature as older humans.
Christopher KaczorExamines personhood, potentiality, consciousness, twinning, bodily autonomy, and other objections to fetal moral status in The Ethics of Abortion.
Scott KlusendorfA prominent pro-life educator who presents the human-equality argument in a concise, publicly accessible form. His SLED test asks whether size, level of development, environment, or degree of dependency can justify killing the unborn.
John FinnisA natural-law philosopher who argues that human life is a basic good and that an individual’s worth does not depend on immediately exercisable abilities.

The SLED Test

Scott Klusendorf popularizes the argument through the acronym SLED:

DifferenceQuestion
SizeDoes being smaller make the unborn child less human or less valuable?
Level of developmentShould less-developed abilities eliminate someone’s basic right to life?
EnvironmentDoes moving through the birth canal change what kind of being the child is?
Degree of dependencyDoes dependence upon another person determine whether someone may be intentionally killed?

Major Objections

Critics argue that belonging to the human species is not enough to establish full moral personhood. They propose that rights arise from characteristics such as consciousness, sentience, self-awareness, desires, or the ability to value one’s own future.

Some also argue that a very early embryo lacks the organized brain structures needed for personal identity. Others point to embryo splitting, which can result in identical twins, and question how a single individual could exist before twinning is no longer possible.

Defenders of the substance view respond that these objections confuse a human being’s present activities with the underlying individual who develops the ability to perform them. Twinning, they argue, can be understood as one organism giving rise to another rather than proving that no organism existed beforehand.

Why the View Matters

The human-equality argument asks a foundational question: Should human rights depend on being human, or on demonstrating certain abilities?

If rights depend on developed capacities, then some human beings may qualify more strongly than others. If rights arise from our shared human nature, the unborn child is included regardless of development, disability, location, or dependency.

The substance view therefore presents abortion not merely as a conflict involving potential human life, but as the intentional killing of an existing human being during an early and highly dependent stage of life.

The unborn are not potential human life, they are human life with potential.