Shield Laws

Shield laws are state laws designed to protect abortion providers, patients, and people who assist with abortions from legal actions brought by another state. They became more common after Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization returned authority over abortion policy to the states.

The protections vary, but a shield law may prevent state officials or courts from:

  • Cooperating with another state’s abortion investigation
  • Enforcing another state’s arrest warrant, subpoena, or civil judgment
  • Extraditing a provider for abortion-related conduct
  • Releasing medical or identifying records
  • Suspending a provider’s license because of an out-of-state case
  • Requiring testimony or evidence in another state’s prosecution

Some shield laws specifically protect doctors who use telehealth to prescribe abortion pills to women located in states where abortion is prohibited. The provider remains in a state where abortion is legal, while a pharmacy mails the medication across state lines. The provider’s state may then refuse to assist if the recipient’s state attempts to investigate, prosecute, extradite, or collect a judgment against that provider.

For example, New York has refused to enforce a Texas judgment against a New York doctor accused of prescribing abortion pills to a Texas woman. New York has also refused Louisiana’s attempt to extradite the doctor. Texas has brought similar litigation against a Delaware nurse practitioner, directly testing how far another state’s shield law can protect an out-of-state provider. Reuters

Shield laws do not repeal abortion restrictions in other states, and they do not necessarily prevent a provider from being sued, charged, or arrested if that provider enters the state bringing the case. Instead, they limit cooperation and enforcement within the shielding state. Their long-term constitutionality remains unsettled, especially when states disagree over which state’s law governs a telehealth prescription mailed across state lines.

Supporters argue that shield laws protect lawful medical care and provider privacy. Pro-life critics argue that they allow providers to intentionally bypass another state’s laws and mail abortion drugs into jurisdictions where unborn children are legally protected.