The Fourteenth Amendment: Substantive Due Process

Personhood is the status of being a person—an individual who possesses moral worth and is owed basic respect and protection. In ordinary language, a person is a human individual. In philosophy and law, however, the term can carry more specific and sometimes disputed meanings.

It is helpful to distinguish three related questions:

  • Biological: Is the being a living human organism?
  • Moral: Does that human being possess inherent value and basic rights?
  • Legal: Does the law officially recognize that being as a person with enforceable rights?

In the abortion debate, the biological identity of the embryo or fetus as a living human organism is distinct from the philosophical question of personhood. The pro-life position holds that every human being is a person from fertilization and that basic rights should not depend on age, size, location, independence, or presently exercisable abilities. Qualities such as consciousness, reasoning, and self-awareness develop gradually, vary among individuals, and may be temporarily absent even in people whose personhood is unquestioned.

Some abortion-rights arguments separate being biologically human from being a person. They place personhood at a later point based on characteristics such as consciousness, the ability to feel pain, viability, or birth. These standards are philosophical or legal judgments; biology alone cannot determine which characteristics should qualify someone for basic rights.

Legal personhood means recognition as a rights-bearing person under the law. In Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court concluded that the word “person” in the Fourteenth Amendment did not include the unborn. Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization later overturned Roe’s constitutional right to abortion, but it did not rule that unborn human beings are Fourteenth Amendment persons. Their federal constitutional status therefore remains unresolved, although states may protect unborn life through their own laws.


Substantive due process is the legal principle that the government cannot unfairly interfere with certain fundamental freedoms protected by the Constitution’s guarantees of “life, liberty, or property.” These freedoms may be protected even when they are not specifically listed in the Constitution. The Fifth Amendment limits the federal government, while the Fourteenth Amendment applies this protection to state and local governments.

Substantive due process is different from procedural due process. Procedural due process asks whether the government used fair procedures, such as providing notice and a hearing. Substantive due process asks a more basic question: does the government have a constitutionally sufficient reason to interfere with this freedom in the first place?

The Supreme Court has used substantive due process to protect certain rights involving marriage, contraception, parenting, family life, and medical decisions. When someone claims that an unlisted freedom is a fundamental constitutional right, the Court often considers whether that freedom is deeply rooted in American history and tradition and essential to a free society.

Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey used substantive due process to protect abortion as a constitutional right. Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022), the Supreme Court ruled that abortion did not qualify for protection under this doctrine. The majority noted that:

  • Abortion was restricted under American law for much of the nation’s history
  • That most states prohibited abortion when the Fourteenth Amendment was adopted in 1868
  • That no state or federal court had recognized a constitutional right to abortion until shortly before Roe

Based on that history, the Court concluded that abortion was not a right deeply rooted in American history and tradition. Authority to regulate abortion was therefore returned primarily to voters and their elected representatives.