What Is Virtue Ethics?

Virtue ethics is an approach to morality that focuses on character, practical wisdom, and human flourishing.

Rather than beginning only with rules, rights, or consequences, virtue ethics asks:

  • What would a wise and virtuous person do?
  • What motives are guiding the decision?
  • Does the action express virtues such as justice, courage, compassion, responsibility, and honesty?
  • Does it reveal vices such as selfishness, cowardice, cruelty, irresponsibility, or callousness?
  • What kind of person will this choice help someone become?
  • Does the choice contribute to a genuinely flourishing human life?

Virtue ethics originated in ancient Greek philosophy, especially the work of Aristotle. It was later developed within Christian philosophy by Thomas Aquinas and revived in modern moral philosophy by thinkers such as G. E. M. Anscombe, Philippa Foot, Alasdair MacIntyre, and Rosalind Hursthouse.

Human Flourishing

The central goal of virtue ethics is human flourishing, often represented by the Greek term eudaimonia.

Flourishing does not simply mean feeling happy or obtaining whatever one wants. It means living a genuinely good and fulfilled human life through reason, relationships, moral excellence, and participation in worthwhile goods.

A flourishing life includes virtues such as:

  • Justice
  • Courage
  • Compassion
  • Honesty
  • Temperance
  • Responsibility
  • Generosity
  • Fidelity
  • Practical wisdom

Virtues are stable qualities of character. A courageous person does not merely perform one courageous action. He or she has developed the judgment, desires, and habits needed to respond courageously across different circumstances.

Practical Wisdom

Virtue ethics recognizes that moral life cannot always be reduced to a formula.

Practical wisdom, or phronesis, is the ability to recognize what matters morally in a particular situation and respond appropriately.

A practically wise person considers:

  • The nature of the action
  • The individuals affected
  • The reasons for acting
  • The person’s responsibilities
  • The circumstances
  • The goods at stake
  • The likely consequences
  • The emotions and attitudes expressed
  • The kind of character revealed

Practical wisdom does not mean that morality is subjective. It means that applying moral principles to complicated human circumstances requires mature judgment.

How Virtue Ethics Differs From Other Approaches

Ethical approachCentral question
Natural Law EthicsDoes the action respect basic human goods and objective moral principles?
Rights Based EthicsWhose rights are involved, and does the action violate them?
ConsequentialismWhich action will produce the best overall consequences?
Bodily Autonomy ViewDoes one person have the right to use another person’s body?
Virtue EthicsWhat would a virtuous person do, and what character, motives, and attitudes does the action express?

Virtue ethics does not necessarily reject rules, rights, or consequences. It places them within a broader account of character and human flourishing.

A person may possess a legal or moral right to perform an action while still exercising that right selfishly, dishonestly, or cruelly. Likewise, an action with beneficial consequences may still reflect injustice or callousness.

Virtue Ethics and Abortion

Virtue ethics approaches abortion differently from theories that begin with fetal personhood or bodily rights.

It asks what the abortion decision reveals about a person’s attitude toward:

  • Human life and death
  • Pregnancy and childbirth
  • Parenthood
  • Sexual responsibility
  • Family relationships
  • Personal sacrifice
  • Vulnerability and dependency
  • The woman’s health and circumstances
  • The unborn child

This approach does not automatically provide one answer in every pregnancy. Different virtue ethicists reach different conclusions because they disagree about human nature, fetal moral status, the goods involved in parenthood, and whether abortion is ever compatible with justice.

Rosalind Hursthouse

Rosalind Hursthouse presented the most influential modern virtue ethics analysis of abortion in her 1991 essay, “Virtue Theory and Abortion.”

Hursthouse argues that abortion cannot be adequately evaluated merely by determining whether the fetus is a person or whether women possess a right to abortion.

Possessing a right does not establish that every exercise of that right is virtuous. A person may act within his or her rights while behaving selfishly, dishonestly, or without proper concern for others.

Hursthouse therefore asks whether obtaining an abortion in particular circumstances would be virtuous, vicious, or neither.

Abortion as a Serious Matter

Hursthouse rejects the idea that abortion is morally comparable to removing an unwanted piece of tissue.

Pregnancy is the process through which human beings come into existence. It is connected to human life, death, parenthood, family, and some of the deepest relationships people experience.

Terminating a pregnancy therefore carries moral significance even if one denies that the fetus possesses the same rights as an adult.

Hursthouse argues that treating abortion as morally trivial can express callousness or a shallow attitude toward human life. She considers abortion a matter of moral seriousness at every stage, although she recognizes that its seriousness may increase as the fetus develops.

Rights Do Not Settle the Moral Question

Hursthouse distinguishes between possessing a right and exercising that right well.

Suppose a woman possesses a moral and legal right to abortion. It would not follow that every abortion is morally good or that motives do not matter.

A person may have a right to refuse help, end a friendship, spend money, or speak harshly. Exercising that right can still be selfish, disloyal, wasteful, or cruel.

Virtue ethics therefore asks not only:

Does she have the right to obtain an abortion?

It also asks:

What reasons, attitudes, and circumstances shape this particular decision?

For Hursthouse, rights language can identify what others may legally compel or prohibit. It does not fully determine whether a person is acting well.

Motives and Circumstances

Virtue ethics takes the woman’s actual circumstances seriously.

An abortion sought to avoid a minor inconvenience may express different attitudes from an abortion sought because pregnancy threatens the woman’s life, she is physically exhausted from repeated pregnancies, or her circumstances make caring for another child exceptionally difficult.

Relevant considerations may include:

  • The woman’s physical and mental health
  • Threats to her life
  • Responsibilities toward existing children
  • Pregnancy resulting from rape
  • Poverty or severe material hardship
  • Pressure or abandonment by the child’s father
  • The woman’s age and maturity
  • Her motives for avoiding parenthood
  • The support available to her
  • Whether previous choices were responsible or reckless

Hursthouse argues that an abortion may sometimes be a morally understandable or even correct decision. She also maintains that a correct decision can remain tragic and may appropriately involve grief or remorse.

Difficult circumstances can make abortion understandable without making the loss of human life morally insignificant.

Parenthood as a Human Good

Hursthouse treats parenthood, family relationships, and childbearing as genuine human goods.

This does not mean every woman must become a mother. Human beings can pursue more worthwhile goods than any single life can contain. A childless person can live a generous, meaningful, and flourishing life.

However, rejecting parenthood for shallow reasons may reveal a distorted understanding of freedom or happiness.

For example, someone might treat a child as an obstacle to comfort, status, leisure, appearance, or a perfectly controlled life. Virtue ethics asks whether that attitude reflects wisdom and proper appreciation of the goods of family life.

The same decision may have a different moral character when a woman is attempting to fulfill serious obligations toward existing children or pursue another genuinely worthwhile vocation.

Responsibility Before Pregnancy

Virtue ethics also examines the choices that preceded pregnancy.

Except in cases of rape, pregnancy ordinarily follows voluntary sexual activity. A virtue ethics analysis may therefore consider whether the individuals involved acted with:

  • Responsibility
  • Honesty
  • Fidelity
  • Self control
  • Respect for one another
  • Awareness of the possibility of conception
  • Willingness to accept the consequences of their actions

An abortion decision may be understandable in the immediate circumstances while those circumstances were partly produced by earlier irresponsibility.

Hursthouse therefore rejects the universal claim that guilt or remorse is never appropriate after abortion. Even when abortion appears to be the best remaining choice, reflection on the choices leading to the pregnancy may reveal failures of responsibility or practical wisdom.

The Responsibility of Men

Virtue ethics does not place the entire moral burden on women.

Men participate in the actions that create pregnancy and may influence abortion decisions through support, abandonment, pressure, manipulation, or coercion.

A man may act viciously by:

  • Pressuring a woman to abort
  • Refusing responsibility for his child
  • Treating sex as disconnected from parenthood
  • Leaving the woman to bear all consequences
  • Withholding emotional or material support
  • Treating abortion as a convenient solution to his own behavior

A virtuous response requires fidelity, responsibility, courage, generosity, and concern for both mother and child.

Virtue Does Not Mean Social Respectability

Virtue ethics does not reduce morality to whatever a society happens to approve.

A society may praise traits or practices that are genuinely unjust. Social expectations may also disguise cowardice, cruelty, prejudice, or selfishness as responsibility.

The virtuous person must evaluate cultural attitudes through practical wisdom and a truthful account of human flourishing.

This matters in abortion debates because both sides can appeal superficially to virtue:

  • Abortion may be described as responsible without asking whether responsibility includes obligations toward the unborn child.
  • Continuing a pregnancy may be praised as courageous without considering whether the woman is being abandoned or denied necessary medical treatment.
  • Compassion may be invoked for the woman while ignoring the child.
  • Concern for the child may be expressed without offering meaningful support to the mother.

Authentic virtue requires an integrated concern for truth, justice, life, responsibility, and compassion.

The Pro Life Application of Virtue Ethics

A pro life virtue ethics analysis begins with the understanding that the unborn child is a living human being.

If the fetus is the woman’s child and possesses fundamental human dignity, then intentionally killing that child cannot be evaluated only through the mother’s motives or difficult circumstances.

The virtues must be directed toward the good of both mother and child.

Justice

Justice requires giving each person what is owed.

If the unborn child is a human being with a right to life, justice requires that the child not be intentionally killed. Compassion for the mother cannot eliminate what is owed to the child.

Virtue must therefore be joined to an accurate understanding of who is affected by the action.

Compassion

Compassion recognizes the woman’s fear, pain, exhaustion, financial distress, health concerns, and difficult relationships.

A pro life account does not treat compassion as mere emotion. Genuine compassion seeks the actual good of the person who is suffering.

It should provide practical help while avoiding an action that intentionally ends another human life.

Courage

Continuing a difficult pregnancy may require great courage. Courage does not mean ignoring danger, refusing medical treatment, or pretending that pregnancy imposes no burden.

It means facing hardship for the sake of genuine goods while acting with practical wisdom.

In a medical emergency, courage may require accepting necessary treatment even when the child cannot survive. The moral question concerns whether the child’s death is intended or is an unavoidable consequence of treating the mother’s dangerous condition.

Responsibility

Responsibility includes accepting obligations created by one’s actions and relationships.

Parents owe forms of care to their children that they do not owe to strangers. A child’s dependency does not eliminate those obligations. It is one reason the child needs protection.

Responsibility also applies to fathers, families, communities, employers, churches, and governments. It is unjust to demand personal sacrifice from women while refusing the support that makes motherhood possible.

Practical Wisdom

Practical wisdom recognizes that not every pregnancy presents the same circumstances.

A pregnant woman may face fear, abandonment, illness, poverty, disability diagnoses, abuse, or threats to her life. These circumstances require careful judgment and concrete assistance.

Practical wisdom identifies morally legitimate ways to protect the mother without intentionally attacking the child.

The Pro Life Critique of Hursthouse

Fetal Status Cannot Be Set Aside

Hursthouse argues that virtue ethics can evaluate abortion without first resolving the philosophical status of the fetus.

The pro life response is that the fetus’s identity is essential.

Whether an abortion ends the life of a person, a valuable developing human being, or morally insignificant tissue radically affects what justice requires.

Motives and circumstances matter, but they cannot determine the morality of an act without considering what the act does and to whom it is done.

Good Motives Cannot Justify Every Action

A woman may seek abortion from fear, concern for existing children, illness, or severe hardship rather than selfishness.

These motives deserve compassion. However, a good motive does not automatically make the chosen action morally permissible.

Someone may act from love or desperation while selecting a means that violates another person’s rights.

Virtue ethics must therefore evaluate:

  • The person’s intention
  • The object of the action
  • The circumstances
  • The effects on everyone involved

Virtue Requires Objective Moral Limits

Without moral limits, practical wisdom can become a process of balancing competing concerns until almost any action appears defensible in difficult circumstances.

The Aristotelian and Thomistic traditions do not treat virtue as a substitute for objective morality. Prudence identifies the right means of pursuing genuine goods. It does not transform an intrinsically unjust act into a virtuous one.

From a pro life perspective, directly and intentionally killing an innocent human being cannot become virtuous because the circumstances are painful.

Abortion Concerns More Than Attitude

A person can recognize that abortion is serious, feel sorrow, and act without callousness while still intentionally ending a human life.

The moral problem is therefore not merely whether someone has a respectful attitude toward pregnancy and death.

The action itself must be evaluated.

Respectful motives may reduce personal blame, but they do not necessarily make the act objectively right.

Virtue Ethics and the Law

Virtue ethics primarily addresses how people should live. It does not automatically determine what conduct government should prohibit.

An action may be vicious without being illegal. Lying to a friend, betraying a confidence, acting selfishly, or neglecting opportunities for generosity may be morally wrong without being crimes.

Hursthouse explicitly distinguishes the morality of abortion from the legality of abortion. Her argument that a particular abortion may be selfish, callous, or irresponsible does not by itself establish that government should prohibit it.

A complete legal argument must also consider:

  • The rights of the unborn child
  • The proper purpose of criminal law
  • The government’s ability to enforce restrictions fairly
  • The treatment of women who obtain abortions
  • The responsibilities of abortion providers
  • Medical emergencies
  • The effects of law on vulnerable families

Pro life legal arguments usually rely on justice and human rights in addition to virtue ethics.

Strengths of Virtue Ethics

Virtue ethics adds several important insights to the abortion debate:

  • Legal rights do not settle every moral question.
  • Motives and attitudes matter.
  • Men also bear moral responsibility.
  • Pregnancy cannot be separated from parenthood and family life.
  • Difficult circumstances affect personal responsibility.
  • Abortion may remain tragic even when someone considers it justified.
  • Social conditions can make virtuous choices much harder.
  • Supporting women and families is part of moral responsibility.
  • Moral maturity requires more than applying slogans.

It also challenges both sides to examine whether their language and actions express justice, compassion, honesty, courage, and respect.

Objections to Virtue Ethics

It Does Not Provide a Clear Rule

Critics argue that asking what a virtuous person would do does not produce a clear answer.

Different people may disagree about whether abortion expresses compassion, responsibility, justice, or selfishness.

Virtue ethicists respond that moral complexity cannot always be eliminated by creating a simple rule. Difficult decisions require practical wisdom, experience, and accurate perception of the circumstances.

Virtues Can Conflict

Compassion for the mother may appear to conflict with justice toward the child. Courage may require continuing a pregnancy in one case and accepting dangerous medical treatment in another.

Virtue ethics must explain how a wise person integrates multiple virtues rather than selecting whichever one supports a preferred conclusion.

Accounts of Flourishing Differ

People disagree about whether parenthood, autonomy, religious vocation, professional achievement, family relationships, or personal independence are central to flourishing.

A virtue ethics argument therefore depends on a defensible account of human nature and the goods that genuinely fulfill human beings.

Character Does Not Replace the Act

Focusing on the agent can obscure what is actually done.

A compassionate person may still perform an unjust act. A frightened or morally immature person may accidentally do what is objectively right.

A complete moral analysis must consider character, intention, circumstances, and the nature of the action itself.

Why Virtue Ethics Matters

Virtue ethics expands the abortion debate beyond competing claims about rights.

It asks what our choices reveal about how we understand freedom, responsibility, motherhood, fatherhood, family, sacrifice, and vulnerable human life.

Its central question is not merely:

Is abortion permitted?

It is:

What response to this pregnancy would express justice, courage, compassion, responsibility, and practical wisdom?

Rosalind Hursthouse uses virtue ethics to argue that abortion can sometimes be morally permissible while always remaining a matter of human seriousness.

The pro life response agrees that character, circumstances, and compassion matter, but argues that the virtues must begin with justice toward the unborn child. If the fetus is a human being with fundamental dignity, intentionally killing that child cannot become virtuous through good motives alone.

Major Thinkers

ThinkerContribution
AristotleDeveloped the classical account of virtue, practical wisdom, and human flourishing
Thomas AquinasIntegrated Aristotelian virtue with natural law, moral intention, and objective human goods
G. E. M. AnscombeHelped revive modern virtue ethics and criticized moral theories detached from character and human flourishing
Philippa FootApplied virtue, natural goodness, intention, and double effect to questions involving life and death
Rosalind HursthouseDeveloped the most influential contemporary virtue ethics analysis of abortion
Alasdair MacIntyreConnected virtue with practices, communities, traditions, and coherent human lives