Infanticide

What Is Infanticide?

Infanticide is the intentional killing of an infant after birth. The precise age range varies across legal systems and academic fields, but the term commonly refers to the killing of a child during the first year of life.

Infanticide is a form of homicide. It is distinguished from deaths caused by natural illness, accident, miscarriage, stillbirth, or complications of childbirth.

In the United States, a child born alive is legally recognized as a person under federal law, regardless of the child’s stage of development or whether the birth resulted from labor, cesarean delivery, or an attempted abortion.

Related Terms

Several related terms have more specific meanings:

  • Neonaticide: The intentional killing of a newborn, commonly defined in research as occurring within the first 24 hours after birth.
  • Filicide: The killing of a son or daughter by a parent, regardless of the child’s age.
  • Infant homicide: A broader legal or statistical term for the killing of an infant.
  • Abortion: The intentional termination of a pregnancy by purposefully ending the unborn’s life.
  • Stillbirth: The death of a child before or during delivery, without signs of life after birth.

Definitions sometimes vary between medical research and national laws. For example, some countries use infanticide as the name of a specific criminal offense involving a mother whose mental condition was severely affected by childbirth. In the United States, the act is generally prosecuted under applicable homicide laws rather than through a single nationwide crime called infanticide.

Infanticide and Medical Care

The death of a severely premature or terminally ill infant is not automatically infanticide.

Doctors and parents may sometimes decide that a treatment is medically futile or imposes burdens disproportionate to its likely benefit. Withholding an extraordinary treatment while continuing ordinary care and comfort measures is different from intentionally causing the child’s death.

The central ethical distinction concerns intention:

  • Allowing a terminal illness to cause death is morally different from causing death as the intended outcome.
  • Providing pain relief is not infanticide when the intention is to relieve suffering rather than cause death.
  • Deliberately withholding ordinary care for the purpose of causing death may constitute infanticide.

Infanticide in Abortion Ethics

Infanticide appears in abortion debates because some theories of personhood base the right to life on immediately exercisable abilities such as consciousness, self awareness, rationality, or a desire to continue living.

Newborn infants do not yet possess all of these abilities in a developed form. If such abilities are necessary for a right to life, the theory may have difficulty explaining why birth creates a decisive moral boundary.

Philosophers including Michael Tooley and Peter Singer have argued that newborns do not possess the same moral status as self-aware persons. Their conclusions are controversial, but they reveal an important implication of capacity-based accounts of personhood.

The pro-life response is that infants possess equal human dignity despite their immaturity and dependency. Their inability to reason, communicate, or understand the future does not make them less human or remove their right to life.

The same principle is applied to unborn children. Birth changes the child’s location and manner of receiving support, but it does not change the kind of being the child is.

Why the Definition Matters

Infanticide should not be confused with abortion because birth creates an important legal distinction. However, the two subjects raise a common philosophical question:

Does the right to life depend on being human, or on possessing certain presently exercisable mental abilities?

The pro-life position holds that every human being possesses basic dignity throughout life, including before birth, during infancy, and during periods of unconsciousness or dependency.

Does the right to life depend on being human, or on possessing certain presently exercisable mental abilities?