Who Is Patrick Lee?

Patrick Lee is an American moral philosopher and longtime professor at Franciscan University of Steubenville. He is best known for his work on abortion, human personhood, natural law, bioethics, and the relationship between the body and the self.

Lee has helped develop one of the most rigorous philosophical defenses of the pro-life position. His best-known book, Abortion and Unborn Human Life, examines prominent arguments supporting abortion and presents a detailed case for the moral status of unborn human beings.

His Argument Against Abortion

Lee’s argument can be summarized as follows:

  1. At fertilization, a new, living human organism begins to exist.
  2. This organism is the same individual who may later become an embryo, fetus, infant, child, and adult.
  3. Human dignity is grounded in what someone is, a human being with a rational nature, rather than in abilities the person can presently exercise.
  4. It is generally wrong to intentionally kill an innocent human being.
  5. Therefore, abortion is generally wrong because it intentionally kills a human being during an early stage of development.

The unborn child does not merely have the potential to become a human organism. The child is already a human organism, although still developing the abilities associated with mature human life.

The Substance View

Lee is closely associated with the substance view of human persons, which he has defended alongside philosopher Robert P. George.

Here, “substance” does not mean a chemical substance. It means an individual being that remains the same underlying entity while undergoing development and change.

Under this view, the embryo does not become a different being when consciousness, viability, or self-awareness develops. The embryo, fetus, newborn, and adult are different developmental stages in the life of the same human individual.

Human Equality

Lee argues that equal human rights cannot safely depend on characteristics such as intelligence, independence, consciousness, or presently exercisable abilities. Human beings possess these characteristics in unequal degrees, and some temporarily or permanently cannot exercise them.

If rights depended upon present mental performance, newborns, unconscious patients, and people with profound cognitive disabilities could possess less moral worth than other human beings. Lee instead grounds equality in our shared human nature.

This does not mean an embryo can presently reason or make decisions. It means the embryo is the kind of living being whose development, when allowed to proceed, includes the natural capacity for rational activity.

Bodily Autonomy

Lee recognizes that pregnancy involves the intimate use of a woman’s body, but argues that bodily autonomy does not automatically justify abortion.

In his view, the relationship between a mother and her unborn child is not adequately represented by comparisons involving two unrelated strangers. Parents ordinarily have special responsibilities toward their dependent children, and abortion generally involves intentionally causing the child’s death rather than merely declining to provide extraordinary assistance.

Critics respond that even if the unborn child is a person, no person has an unlimited right to use another person’s body. Lee maintains that bodily rights are important but not absolute and must be considered alongside the child’s right not to be intentionally killed.

Major Works

WorkSignificance
Abortion and Unborn Human LifeLee’s principal examination of the philosophical arguments surrounding abortion and unborn human life
“The Wrong of Abortion,” with Robert P. GeorgeA concise defense of the claim that abortion unjustly kills a human being
Body-Self Dualism in Contemporary Ethics and Politics, with Robert P. GeorgeArgues that a human person is a bodily organism, not merely a conscious mind inhabiting a body
“Embryonic Human Persons,” with Robert P. GeorgeDefends the humanity and moral status of human embryos, particularly in debates about embryo research

Influence

Patrick Lee is an important academic thinker within the modern pro-life movement. While public advocates often present short arguments about the unborn, Lee provides a deeper philosophical foundation connecting embryology, human identity, natural law, equality, and human rights.

His work is frequently considered alongside that of Robert P. George, John Finnis, Francis Beckwith, Christopher Kaczor, and other philosophers who defend the equal moral worth of human beings throughout their lives.